de Pedro-Cuesta J, Stawiarz L
Unit for Neuroepidemiology and Health Services Research, Huddinge Hospital, Karolinska Institute, Sweden.
Acta Neurol Scand. 1991 Nov;84(5):382-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0404.1991.tb04974.x.
In this study, we reviewed incidence surveys of Parkinson's Disease (PD) from all over the world, published during the period 1945-1989, using reported quality criteria. In addition, we compared age-specific PD incidences from selected observations by stratified analysis. Crude incidences were described for 11 populations, and age-specific incidences for three of them: Iceland, Rochester (Minn, USA), and Turku (Finland). Effect modification by age was detected: a) by comparing incidences by age at diagnosis with incidence by age at clinical disease onset; and b) when only data on onset of disease was computed. For disease onsets, the incidences in Rochester for the period 1955-1966, and in Turku (Finland) during the interval 1968-1970, were lower than that in Iceland for the period 1958-1960: RR = 0.58 95% CI (0.41, 0.83), and RR = 0.67 95% CI (0.51, 0.87), respectively. For the Rochester population aged 40-69 years, a statistically significant 56% decrease in the incidences of Parkinsonism onsets during the period 1945-1966 was found. Validity problems in comparing PD incidences and the role of PD underdiagnosis were emphasized. We concluded that: a) stratified analysis is more suitable than standardization when comparing incidences for etiological purposes; b) the incidence of PD was highest in Iceland; and c) in Rochester, PD incidence under the age of 70 decreased with time.
在本研究中,我们使用报告的质量标准,回顾了1945年至1989年期间发表的来自世界各地的帕金森病(PD)发病率调查。此外,我们通过分层分析比较了选定观察对象的年龄特异性PD发病率。描述了11个人群的粗发病率,以及其中三个人群的年龄特异性发病率:冰岛、罗切斯特(美国明尼苏达州)和图尔库(芬兰)。检测到年龄对效应的修饰作用:a)通过比较诊断时年龄的发病率与临床疾病发病时年龄的发病率;b)仅计算疾病发病数据时。对于疾病发病情况,1955年至1966年期间罗切斯特的发病率,以及1968年至1970年期间图尔库(芬兰)的发病率,低于1958年至1960年期间冰岛的发病率:相对危险度(RR)分别为0.58,95%可信区间(CI)(0.41,0.83),以及RR = 0.67,95%CI(0.51,0.87)。对于40至69岁的罗切斯特人群,发现在1945年至1966年期间帕金森病发病的发病率有统计学意义的56%下降。强调了比较PD发病率时的有效性问题以及PD诊断不足的作用。我们得出结论:a)出于病因学目的比较发病率时,分层分析比标准化更合适;b)冰岛的PD发病率最高;c)在罗切斯特,70岁以下的PD发病率随时间下降。