Strömgren L S
Aarhus University, Department of Psychiatry, Denmark.
Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1991 Nov;84(5):428-34. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1991.tb03173.x.
In 1977 a questionnaire was sent to all psychiatric departments in the Nordic countries: Sweden, Norway, Denmark, Finland and Iceland, concerning indications for electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) and the use of unilateral and bilateral treatment, respectively. The inquiry was repeated in 1987 and the answers compared with those obtained in 1977. In addition, the answers from Denmark were compared with previously performed inquiries. The use of exclusively unilateral treatment (U) and of both unilateral and bilateral treatment (UB) has increased in most of the countries and exclusively bilateral treatment (B) has decreased drastically. In Denmark the situation has not changed for ECT in endogenous depression and acute delirium, and the use in reactive psychosis, mania and schizophrenia decreased somewhat during the 1970s and then again stabilized or increased during the 1980s. Nearly all departments in the Nordic countries used ECT in endogenous depression in 1977 and were still doing it in 1987. In mania, about 50% of all departments have found ECT indicated occasionally or exceptionally both in 1977 and 1987. Manic-depressive mixed states have been regarded as an indication in somewhat more than two thirds of departments, increasing during the period. The use of ECT in schizophrenia has been rare and somewhat decreasing, but still about half of the departments apply it once in a while. In reactive psychosis the use of ECT decreased slightly, but in 1987 it was still in use for this indication in about 50% of all departments. In acute delirium there has been an overall increase in the use of ECT.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
1977年,一份调查问卷被发送至北欧国家(瑞典、挪威、丹麦、芬兰和冰岛)的所有精神科,内容涉及电休克治疗(ECT)的适应症以及单侧和双侧治疗的使用情况。1987年重复了此项调查,并将答案与1977年获得的答案进行比较。此外,还将丹麦的答案与之前进行的调查结果作了比较。在大多数国家,仅采用单侧治疗(U)以及同时采用单侧和双侧治疗(UB)的情况有所增加,而仅采用双侧治疗(B)的情况则大幅下降。在丹麦,内源性抑郁症和急性谵妄中ECT的使用情况未变,反应性精神病、躁狂症和精神分裂症的使用在20世纪70年代有所下降,之后在80年代再次稳定或增加。1977年北欧国家几乎所有科室都在内源性抑郁症中使用ECT,1987年仍如此。在躁狂症方面,1977年和1987年约50%的科室偶尔或特别指出ECT适用。超过三分之二的科室认为躁狂抑郁混合状态适用ECT,这一比例在此期间有所增加。ECT在精神分裂症中的使用很少且有所下降,但仍约有一半的科室偶尔使用。在反应性精神病中ECT的使用略有下降,但1987年仍约50%的科室将其用于此适应症。在急性谵妄中ECT的使用总体有所增加。(摘要截选于250词)