Besaggio Davide, Fuselli Silvia, Srikummool Metawee, Kampuansai Jatupol, Castrì Loredana, Tyler-Smith Chris, Seielstad Mark, Kangwanpong Daoroong, Bertorelle Giorgio
Dipartimento di Biologia ed Evoluzione, Università di Ferrara, via L, Borsari 46, 44100 Ferrara, Italy.
BMC Evol Biol. 2007 Aug 16;7 Suppl 2(Suppl 2):S12. doi: 10.1186/1471-2148-7-S2-S12.
Ethnic minorities in Northern Thailand, often referred to as Hill Tribes, are considered an ideal model to study the different genetic impact of sex-specific migration rates expected in matrilocal (women remain in their natal villages after the marriage and men move to their wife's village) and patrilocal societies (the opposite is true). Previous studies identified such differences, but little is known about the possible interaction with another cultural factor that may potentially affect genetic diversity, i.e. linguistic differences. In addition, Hill Tribes started to migrate to Thailand in the last centuries from different Northern areas, but the history of these migrations, the level of genetic legacy with their places of origin, and the possible confounding effects related to this migration history in the patterns of genetic diversity, have not been analysed yet. Using both original and published data on the Hill Tribes and several other Asian populations, we focused on all these aspects.
Genetic variation within population at mtDNA is lower in matrilocal, compared to patrilocal, tribes. The opposite is true for Y-chromosome microsatellites within the Sino-Tibetan linguistic family, but Hmong-Mien speaking patrilocal groups have a genetic diversity very similar to the matrilocal samples. Population divergence ranges between 5% and 14% at mtDNA sequences, and between 5% and 36% at Y-chromosomes STRs, and follows the sex-specific differences expected in patrilocal and matrilocal tribes. On the average, about 2 men and 14 women, and 4 men and 4 women, are exchanged in patrilocal and matrilocal tribes every generation, respectively. Most of the Hill Tribes in Thailand seem to preserve a genetic legacy with their likely geographic origin, with children adoption probably affecting this pattern in one tribe.
Overall, the sex specific genetic signature of different postmarital habits of residence in the Hill Tribes is robust. However, specific perturbations related to linguistic differences, population specific traits, and the complex migratory history of these groups, can be identified. Additional studies in different populations are needed, especially to obtain more precise estimates of the migration parameters.
泰国北部的少数民族,通常被称为山地部落,被认为是研究母系定居社会(女性婚后留在娘家村落,男性迁至妻子的村落)和父系定居社会(情况相反)中性别特异性迁移率对基因产生不同影响的理想模型。以往的研究发现了此类差异,但对于可能与另一个潜在影响基因多样性的文化因素(即语言差异)之间的相互作用却知之甚少。此外,山地部落于过去几个世纪从不同的北方地区开始向泰国迁移,然而这些迁移的历史、与原居地的基因传承水平以及这种迁移历史在基因多样性模式中可能产生的混杂效应,尚未得到分析。利用关于山地部落及其他几个亚洲人群的原始数据和已发表数据,我们聚焦于所有这些方面。
与父系定居部落相比,母系定居部落线粒体DNA的群体内基因变异更低。在汉藏语系中,Y染色体微卫星的情况则相反,但说苗瑶语的父系定居群体的基因多样性与母系定居样本非常相似。线粒体DNA序列的群体分化在5%至14%之间,Y染色体短串联重复序列的群体分化在5%至36%之间,且符合父系定居和母系定居部落预期的性别特异性差异。平均而言,父系定居部落和母系定居部落每代分别交换约2名男性和14名女性,以及4名男性和4名女性。泰国的大多数山地部落似乎保留了与可能的地理起源地的基因传承,收养子女可能在一个部落中影响了这种模式。
总体而言,山地部落不同婚后居住习惯的性别特异性基因特征是显著的。然而,可以识别出与语言差异、群体特异性特征以及这些群体复杂的迁移历史相关的特定干扰因素。需要在不同人群中开展更多研究,尤其是为了获得更精确的迁移参数估计值。