Riddell James, Hillman Lybus, Chiragakis Louise, Clarke Anthony
Calvary Clinic, Canberra, Australian Capital Territory, Australia.
J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2007 Oct;22(10):1589-93. doi: 10.1111/j.1440-1746.2007.05128.x.
To perform a qualitative retrospective review of identified cases of collagenous colitis within the patient databases of local clinicians, with particular attention to the use and effectiveness of oral low-dose methotrexate.
Gastroenterologists in the referral area were invited to identify collagenous colitis cases from their own databases for inclusion in the study. Patients were considered eligible if they had a symptom history and colonic mucosal histology consistent with collagenous colitis. The retrospective analysis identified age at diagnosis, previous therapies, date of commencement and duration and effectiveness of methotrexate, side-effects, and repeat colonic mucosal histology (if available) after a period of treatment.
Between 1986 and 2003, 43 eligible patients were identified, ranging in age from 32 years to 88 years at the time of diagnosis. Nineteen of the 43 received methotrexate over varying periods, and in 16 of these the clinical response was considered either 'Good' (14) or 'Partial' (2). In the methotrexate group 10 of the 19 underwent repeat colonoscopy and mucosal biopsy at some stage after commencing methotrexate. Of these, five had normal histology in comparison with pretreatment abnormal histology, two had improvement but not normalization of histology, and three had unchanged abnormal histology.
The data from this retrospective review suggest that methotrexate may have a beneficial effect on symptoms of collagenous colitis and may improve the underlying histological abnormality. A controlled trial of adequate power and duration is needed to further clarify the usefulness of methotrexate in this condition.
对当地临床医生患者数据库中已确诊的胶原性结肠炎病例进行定性回顾性研究,特别关注口服低剂量甲氨蝶呤的使用情况及疗效。
邀请转诊区域的胃肠病学家从他们自己的数据库中识别胶原性结肠炎病例以纳入研究。如果患者有与胶原性结肠炎相符的症状史和结肠黏膜组织学检查结果,则被认为符合入选标准。回顾性分析确定了诊断时的年龄、既往治疗方法、甲氨蝶呤开始使用的日期、持续时间和疗效、副作用以及治疗一段时间后的重复结肠黏膜组织学检查结果(如有)。
在1986年至2003年期间,共识别出43例符合条件的患者,诊断时年龄在32岁至88岁之间。43例患者中有19例在不同时间段接受了甲氨蝶呤治疗,其中16例的临床反应被认为是“良好”(14例)或“部分改善”(2例)。在甲氨蝶呤治疗组中,19例患者中有10例在开始使用甲氨蝶呤后的某个阶段接受了重复结肠镜检查和黏膜活检。其中,5例与治疗前异常组织学相比组织学正常,2例组织学有改善但未恢复正常,3例异常组织学无变化。
这项回顾性研究的数据表明,甲氨蝶呤可能对胶原性结肠炎的症状有有益影响,并可能改善潜在的组织学异常。需要进行一项有足够样本量和持续时间的对照试验,以进一步明确甲氨蝶呤在这种疾病中的作用。