Cook Chad, Hannley Maureen, Richardson Jan K, Michon John, Harker Matthew, Pietrobon Ricardo
Division of Physical Therapy, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA.
Account Res. 2007 Jan-Mar;14(1):1-18. doi: 10.1080/08989620601003471.
Meta-analyses involve a systematic statistical explanation of available evidence and are a commonly used systematic reviewing strategy for addressing health related scientific research. Publication biases often delay reporting of meta-analyses and subsequent policy making. Ontologies have the capacity to provide real time meta-analyses that can reduce publication delay. The purpose of this study was to describe the meta-analytic process of a recently revised ontology. Three recently published meta-analyses were replicated using an ontology that extracts appropriate statistical "tags" from the originally reviewed published manuscripts. The ontology was able to closely represent the findings of the original meta-analysis including funnel, forest, and summary statistics. The use of an ontology could improve the speed in which meta-analytic publications occur as well as potentially standardizing the required elements within a randomized controlled trial. The findings in this study demonstrate similar ontological output as used in the Trial Bank Project with decreased time requirements of the manuscript author and the software programmers. The use of an ontology may improve the reporting of meta-analysis and, when combined with an open access website, should assist in timely policy-making decisions by healthcare providers.
元分析涉及对现有证据进行系统的统计学阐释,是用于处理健康相关科研的常用系统综述策略。发表偏倚常常会延迟元分析报告以及后续的政策制定。本体论有能力提供实时元分析,从而减少发表延迟。本研究的目的是描述一个近期修订的本体论的元分析过程。使用一个能从最初审阅的已发表手稿中提取适当统计学“标签”的本体论,对三项近期发表的元分析进行了复制。该本体论能够紧密呈现原始元分析的结果,包括漏斗图、森林图和汇总统计数据。使用本体论可以提高元分析出版物的发表速度,并有可能使随机对照试验中的所需要素标准化。本研究中的发现表明,该本体论的输出与试验库项目中使用的类似,同时减少了手稿作者和软件程序员所需的时间。本体论的使用可能会改善元分析的报告情况,并且与开放获取网站相结合时,应有助于医疗保健提供者及时做出政策决策。