Gill P J, McCoy G F, McClelland C J, Nixon J R, Mollan R A
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, The Queen's University of Belfast.
Ulster Med J. 1991 Oct;60(2):183-92.
One hundred consecutive Richard's Maximum Contact (RMC) knee replacements were performed in Belfast between 1978 and 1982. Most of the 100 knees (86 patients) involved had been in severe pain, had marked stiffness or gross knee deformity, or were chairbound because of the knee. They were reviewed between five and eight and a half years (mean five years and eleven months) after operation. Thirteen patients (13 knees) died before review leaving eighty seven knees in 73 patients available for study. Using a modification of the British Orthopaedic Association knee function assessment chart, 26 knees (30%) were graded as excellent, 22 (25%) as good, 19 (22%) as fair and nine (10%) as poor. There were five implant failures, four the result of deep infection, one due to loosening. Six patients were chairbound at review and were also graded as failures. These results support the view that total knee replacement approaches the predictability and success of arthroplasty of the hip.
1978年至1982年间,在贝尔法斯特连续进行了100例理查德最大接触(RMC)膝关节置换手术。这100例膝关节置换手术涉及的大多数患者(86例)此前一直遭受剧痛,膝关节严重僵硬或严重畸形,或因膝关节问题而只能依靠轮椅行动。在术后五至八年半(平均五年零十一个月)对这些患者进行了复查。13例患者(13个膝关节)在复查前死亡,剩余73例患者的87个膝关节可供研究。采用改良后的英国骨科学会膝关节功能评估表进行评估,结果显示26个膝关节(30%)评定为优,22个(25%)为良,19个(22%)为中,9个(10%)为差。有5例植入物出现故障,其中4例是深部感染所致,1例是松动所致。6例患者在复查时仍需依靠轮椅行动,也被评定为手术失败。这些结果支持了以下观点,即全膝关节置换术在可预测性和成功率方面已接近髋关节置换术。