Garvin K L, Pellicci P M, Windsor R E, Conrad E U, Insall J N, Salvati E A
Knee Service and the Hip Service, Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, N.Y. 10021.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1989 Oct;71(9):1355-62.
We studied the cases of twenty patients who had had an ipsilateral total knee arthroplasty or a contralateral total hip arthroplasty, or both, long after one hip had been fused in an acceptable position. Between 1972 and 1986, we performed twenty-one total joint arthroplasties (on thirteen hips and eight knees) and followed two additional patients (one hip and one knee) in whom the operation had been performed elsewhere. The average age of the patients at the time of arthroplasty was fifty-seven years (range, thirty-one to eighty-one years), and the average time from arthrodesis to arthroplasty was thirty-two years (range, eleven to fifty-four years). The results of eighteen of the twenty-three arthroplasties were evaluated at an average of seven years and nine months postoperatively. Four of the remaining five patients, who were followed for an average of eight years, died of a cause that was unrelated to the arthroplasty. After the hip arthroplasty, five hips were rated excellent; five, good; one, fair; and three, poor. Each hip that had a poor result was revised twice for mechanical loosening. Three hips for which the result was not considered poor had progressive radiolucency. After the knee arthroplasty, three knees were rated excellent; four, good; one, fair; and one, poor (because of infection). Seven knees were manipulated a total of fifteen times. Only one patient had progressive symptomatic radiolucency, nine years after the insertion of a posterior stabilized prosthesis. Clinically important ligamentous instability was not encountered.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
我们研究了20例患者的病例,这些患者在一侧髋关节已融合于可接受位置很久之后,接受了同侧全膝关节置换术或对侧全髋关节置换术,或两者皆有。1972年至1986年期间,我们进行了21例全关节置换术(13例髋关节和8例膝关节),并随访了另外2例在其他地方接受手术的患者(1例髋关节和1例膝关节)。置换术时患者的平均年龄为57岁(范围为31至81岁),从关节融合到置换术的平均时间为32年(范围为11至54年)。23例置换术中18例的结果在术后平均7年9个月时进行了评估。其余5例患者平均随访8年,其中4例死于与置换术无关的原因。髋关节置换术后,5例髋关节评定为优;5例为良;1例为中;3例为差。结果差的每个髋关节均因机械性松动进行了两次翻修。结果未被视为差的3例髋关节有进行性透亮线。膝关节置换术后,3例膝关节评定为优;4例为良;1例为中;1例为差(因感染)。7例膝关节共进行了15次手法操作。仅1例患者在植入后稳定型假体9年后出现进行性有症状的透亮线。未遇到具有临床意义的韧带不稳定情况。(摘要截短至250字)