Juliano Steven A
Dept. of Biological Sciences, Behavior, Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics Group, Illinois State University, Normal, IL 61790-4120, USA.
J Am Mosq Control Assoc. 2007;23(2 Suppl):265-75. doi: 10.2987/8756-971X(2007)23[265:PD]2.0.CO;2.
This chapter reviews aspects of population dynamics that may be conceptually important for biological control of mosquitoes. Density dependent population regulation among immature stages has important implications for biological control of mosquito populations, primarily because it can lead to compensatory or overcompensatory mortality due to additions of a biological control agent. This can result in control efforts leading to no change in the target population, or actual increases in the target population, respectively. Density dependent effects, and compensatory or overcompensatory mortality, appear to be most common in mosquitoes from container or highly ephemeral habitats. In permanent ground water habitats generalist predators appear to limit mosquito populations and so render mortality additive. Thus, biological control in permanent ground water habitats seems to have the highest likelihood of producing a satisfactory result. A central premise of classical biological control is that pest populations are reduced by enemies to stable equilibrium levels that are both below the pre-control equilibrium level, and well below the level producing detrimental effects. This premise results in predictions that successful biological control is likely to involve specialist enemies (usually parasitoids), with short generation times relative to the victim, high rates of successful search, rapid rates of increase, and needing only a few victims to complete their life cycle. These predictions largely fail for mosquito systems, in which successful biological control seems to be associated with generalist enemies that can kill a large portion of the target population, often causing local extinction, and can persist in the absence of the target organism. Biological control of mosquitoes appears to be inherently unstable, thus contrasting sharply with classical biological control. This review suggests a need for better data on density dependent regulation of mosquito populations.
本章回顾了种群动态的各个方面,这些方面在蚊子的生物防治中可能具有重要的概念意义。未成熟阶段的密度依赖性种群调节对蚊子种群的生物防治具有重要影响,主要是因为引入生物防治剂可能导致补偿性或超补偿性死亡。这可能分别导致防治措施对目标种群没有影响,或目标种群实际增加。密度依赖性效应以及补偿性或超补偿性死亡似乎在来自容器或高度短暂栖息地的蚊子中最为常见。在永久性地下水栖息地,广食性捕食者似乎会限制蚊子种群数量,从而使死亡率具有累加性。因此,在永久性地下水栖息地进行生物防治似乎最有可能产生令人满意的结果。经典生物防治的一个核心前提是,害虫种群被天敌减少到稳定的平衡水平,该水平既低于防治前的平衡水平,又远低于产生有害影响的水平。这一前提导致的预测是,成功的生物防治可能涉及专门的天敌(通常是寄生蜂),相对于受害者而言世代时间短、成功搜索率高、繁殖速度快,并且只需少数受害者就能完成其生命周期。这些预测在蚊子系统中大多不成立,在蚊子系统中,成功的生物防治似乎与广食性天敌有关,这些天敌可以杀死很大一部分目标种群,常常导致局部灭绝,并且在没有目标生物的情况下也能持续存在。蚊子的生物防治似乎本质上是不稳定的,因此与经典生物防治形成鲜明对比。这篇综述表明需要有关于蚊子种群密度依赖性调节的更好数据。