Comparison of gene sets for expression profiling: prediction of metastasis from low-malignant breast cancer.

PURPOSE

In the low-risk group of breast cancer patients, a subgroup experiences metastatic recurrence of the disease. The aim of this study was to examine the performance of gene sets, developed mainly from high-risk tumors, in a group of low-malignant tumors.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

Twenty-six tumors from low-risk patients and 34 low-malignant T2 tumors from patients with slightly higher risk have been examined by genome-wide gene expression analysis. Nine prognostic gene sets were tested in this data set.

RESULTS

A 32-gene profile (HUMAC32) that accurately predicts metastasis has previously been developed from this data set. In the present study, six of the eight other gene sets have prognostic power in the low-malignant patient group, whereas two have no prognostic value. Despite a relatively small overlap between gene sets, there is high concordance of classification of samples. This, together with analysis of functional gene groups, indicates that the same pathways may be represented by several of the gene sets. However, the results suggest that low-risk patients may be classified more accurately with gene signatures developed especially for this patient group.

CONCLUSION

Several gene sets, mainly developed in high-risk cancers, predict metastasis from low-malignant cancer.