Lazarus Paul A
Department of Medical and Social Care Education, University of Leicester School of Medicine, Leicester, UK.
Med Teach. 2007 Jun;29(5):478-83. doi: 10.1080/01421590701509621.
The Final Professional Examination for medical students at Leicester Medical School involves the use of real patients, and senior clinicians assess students over a series of consultations with these patients. What the patients themselves think of the students is not known.
This qualitative study identifies the perceptions and opinions which patients who have been used in this examination have of the student candidates, and whether these may be used to enhance the training of medical students.
Patients who had participated in a number of examination diets were interviewed in either a group interview or individually. The interviews were loosely structured in order to discover the experiences that these patients had and how they interpreted them. Data was analysed inductively using the constant comparative method.
The large majority of views of patients fell into the following categories: observations on student conduct during the examination (both in terms of affective and professional behaviours), demographic characteristics of students and views on student performance.
Based on the results of this study, educational recommendations are made which might improve student performance in the examination and lead to greater patient satisfaction with the 'end product' of the medical school, namely the graduating student. These include the incorporation of students' observation of infection control measures within the assessment schedule, and more direct preparation of students in handling uncertainty and their anxieties within the consultation.
莱斯特医学院医学生的专业结业考试涉及使用真实患者,资深临床医生通过与这些患者进行一系列会诊来评估学生。但患者对学生的看法尚不清楚。
这项定性研究旨在确定参与该考试的患者对学生考生的看法和意见,以及这些看法和意见是否可用于加强医学生的培训。
对参加过多次考试轮次的患者进行小组访谈或个人访谈。访谈结构较为宽松,以了解这些患者的经历以及他们对这些经历的解读。使用持续比较法对数据进行归纳分析。
患者的绝大多数观点可分为以下几类:对考试期间学生行为的观察(包括情感行为和专业行为)、学生的人口统计学特征以及对学生表现的看法。
基于本研究结果,提出了一些教育建议,这些建议可能会提高学生在考试中的表现,并使患者对医学院的“最终产品”(即即将毕业的学生)更满意。这些建议包括在评估计划中纳入学生对感染控制措施的观察,以及更直接地让学生准备如何在会诊中应对不确定性和焦虑情绪。