Munteanu Shannon E, Strawhorn Andrea B, Landorf Karl B, Bird Adam R, Murley George S
Department of Podiatry, Faculty of Health Sciences, La Trobe University, Australia.
J Sci Med Sport. 2009 Jan;12(1):54-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jsams.2007.06.009. Epub 2007 Sep 20.
Measurement of ankle joint dorsiflexion is routinely undertaken by clinicians who manage lower limb musculoskeletal pathology. This study aimed to determine the reliability of a technique to measure ankle joint dorsiflexion in a weightbearing position with the knee extended. Four raters with varying clinical experience measured ankle joint dorsiflexion in a weightbearing position with the knee extended on 30 asymptomatic participants. Measurements occurred on two occasions, 1 week apart using (i) a digital inclinometer and (ii) a clear acrylic plate apparatus. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) and 95% limits of agreement (LOAs) were calculated. Intra-rater reliability of the experienced raters was high for both the digital inclinometer (average ICC=0.88, average 95% LOA=-6.6 degrees to 4.8 degrees ) and the clear acrylic plate apparatus (average ICC=0.89, average 95% LOA=-7.2 degrees to 4.3 degrees ). Intra-rater reliability of the inexperienced rater was good to high for both the digital inclinometer (ICC=0.77, 95% LOA=-9.1 degrees to 8.3 degrees ) and the clear acrylic plate apparatus (ICC=0.89, 95% LOA=-8.1 degrees to 4.6 degrees ). Inter-rater reliability was high for both the digital inclinometer (ICC=0.95, 95% LOA=-5.7 degrees to 5.7 degrees ) and the clear acrylic plate apparatus (ICC=0.97, 95% LOA=-4.7 degrees to 4.7 degrees ). Measurements of ankle dorsiflexion in a weightbearing position with the knee extended can be performed reliably by experienced and inexperienced raters. However, the reliability of this measurement technique needs to be interpreted in the context of the purpose for which the measurement is intended.
管理下肢肌肉骨骼疾病的临床医生通常会对踝关节背屈进行测量。本研究旨在确定一种在膝关节伸展的负重位测量踝关节背屈技术的可靠性。四名临床经验不同的评估者对30名无症状参与者在膝关节伸展的负重位测量踝关节背屈。测量分两次进行,间隔1周,使用(i)数字倾角仪和(ii)透明丙烯酸板装置。计算组内相关系数(ICC)和95%一致性界限(LOA)。经验丰富的评估者使用数字倾角仪(平均ICC = 0.88,平均95% LOA = -6.6度至4.8度)和透明丙烯酸板装置(平均ICC = 0.89,平均95% LOA = -7.2度至4.3度)时,评估者内可靠性都很高。经验不足的评估者使用数字倾角仪(ICC = 0.77,95% LOA = -9.1度至8.3度)和透明丙烯酸板装置(ICC = 0.89,95% LOA = -8.1度至4.6度)时,评估者内可靠性为良好至高度。评估者间可靠性对于数字倾角仪(ICC = 0.95,95% LOA = -5.7度至5.7度)和透明丙烯酸板装置(ICC = 0.97,95% LOA = -4.7度至4.7度)都很高。经验丰富和经验不足的评估者都能可靠地进行膝关节伸展的负重位踝关节背屈测量。然而,这种测量技术的可靠性需要根据测量目的来解释。