Bowers Stephanie L, Bilbo Staci D, Dhabhar Firdaus S, Nelson Randy J
Departments of Psychology, Neuroscience, and Institute for Behavioral Medicine Research, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210, USA.
Brain Behav Immun. 2008 Jan;22(1):105-13. doi: 10.1016/j.bbi.2007.07.012. Epub 2007 Sep 24.
Different stressors likely elicit different physiological and behavioral responses. Previously reported differences in the effects of stressors on immune function may reflect qualitatively different physiological responses to stressors; alternatively, both large and subtle differences in testing protocols and methods among laboratories may make direct comparisons among studies difficult. Here we examine the effects of chronic stressors on plasma corticosterone concentrations, leukocyte redistribution, and skin delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH), and the effects of acute stressors on plasma corticosterone and leukocyte redistribution. The effects of several commonly used laboratory stressors including restraint, forced swim, isolation, and low ambient temperatures (4 degrees C) were examined. Exposure to each stressor elevated corticosterone concentrations, with restraint (a putative psychological stressor) evoking a significantly higher glucocorticoid response than other stressors. Chronic restraint and forced swim enhanced the DTH response compared to the handled, low temperature, or isolation conditions. Restraint, low temperature, and isolation significantly increased trafficking of lymphocytes and monocytes compared to forced swim or handling. Generally, acute restraint, low temperature, isolation, and handling increased trafficking of lymphocytes and monocytes. Considered together, our results suggest that the different stressors commonly used in psychoneuroimmunology research may not activate the physiological stress response to the same extent. The variation observed in the measured immune responses may reflect differential glucocorticoid activation, differential metabolic adjustments, or both processes in response to specific stressors.
不同的应激源可能引发不同的生理和行为反应。先前报道的应激源对免疫功能影响的差异可能反映了对应激源在性质上不同的生理反应;或者,各实验室在测试方案和方法上的显著及细微差异可能使得不同研究之间难以进行直接比较。在此,我们研究慢性应激源对血浆皮质酮浓度、白细胞再分布以及皮肤迟发型超敏反应(DTH)的影响,以及急性应激源对血浆皮质酮和白细胞再分布的影响。我们考察了几种常用的实验室应激源的作用,包括束缚、强迫游泳、隔离以及低环境温度(4摄氏度)。接触每种应激源都会使皮质酮浓度升高,其中束缚(一种假定的心理应激源)引发的糖皮质激素反应显著高于其他应激源。与处理组、低温组或隔离组相比,慢性束缚和强迫游泳增强了DTH反应。与强迫游泳或处理组相比,束缚、低温和隔离显著增加了淋巴细胞和单核细胞的转运。一般来说,急性束缚、低温、隔离和处理会增加淋巴细胞和单核细胞的转运。综合来看,我们的结果表明,心理神经免疫学研究中常用的不同应激源可能不会在相同程度上激活生理应激反应。所观察到的免疫反应变化可能反映了针对特定应激源的糖皮质激素激活差异、代谢调节差异或两者兼而有之。