Fertig Angela R, Reingold David A
College of Public Health, Carl Vinson Institute of Government, University of Georgia, USA.
J Policy Anal Manage. 2007 Autumn;26(4):831-59. doi: 10.1002/pam.20288.
This paper explores the relationship between public housing, health outcomes, and health behaviors among low-income housing residents. While public housing can be a dangerous and unhealthy environment in which to live, the subsidized rent may free up resources for nutritious food and health care. In addition, public housing may be of higher quality than the available alternatives, it may provide easier access to health clinics willing to serve the poor, and it may link residents to social support networks, which can improve mental health and the ability to access higher-quality grocery stores. To test whether there is a "back-door" health benefit to the public housing program, we analyze data from the Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study. We minimize the effects of selection into public housing with controls and instrumental variables estimation and find that the results are somewhat sensitive to the instrumental variable used, and thus, we conclude that we are unable to detect a robust health benefit from public housing for our measures of health. However, we do find some evidence that public housing residency has mixed effects on domestic violence, increases obesity, and worsens mothers' overall health status.
本文探讨了低收入住房居民中公共住房、健康结果和健康行为之间的关系。虽然公共住房可能是一个危险且不健康的居住环境,但补贴租金可能会释放出用于购买营养食品和医疗保健的资源。此外,公共住房的质量可能高于其他可选择的住房,它可能使居民更容易前往愿意为贫困人口服务的健康诊所,并且它可能将居民与社会支持网络联系起来,这可以改善心理健康状况以及前往更高质量杂货店购物的能力。为了检验公共住房项目是否存在“间接”的健康益处,我们分析了脆弱家庭与儿童福利研究的数据。我们通过控制变量和工具变量估计来尽量减少选择进入公共住房所带来的影响,结果发现,结果对所使用的工具变量有些敏感,因此,我们得出结论,对于我们所采用的健康指标,我们无法检测到公共住房带来的显著健康益处。然而,我们确实发现一些证据表明,居住在公共住房对家庭暴力有复杂的影响,会增加肥胖率,并恶化母亲的整体健康状况。