Fox Patrick, Porter Patricia G, Lob Sibylle H, Boer Jennifer Holloman, Rocha David A, Adelson Joel W
Institute for Health & Aging, University of California, 3333 California St, San Francisco, CA 94118, USA.
Pediatrics. 2007 Oct;120(4):e902-11. doi: 10.1542/peds.2006-1805.
The purpose of this work was to improve asthma-related health outcomes in an ethnically and geographically disparate population of economically disadvantaged school-aged children by using a team-based approach using continuous quality improvement and community health workers.
A demonstration project was conducted with 7 community clinics treating approximately 3000 children with asthma 5 to 18 years of age. The overall clinic population with asthma was assessed for care-process changes through random cross-sectional chart reviews at baseline and 24 months (N = 560). A subset of patients with either moderate or severe persistent asthma or poorly controlled asthma (N = 405) was followed longitudinally for specific asthma-related clinical outcomes, satisfaction with care, and confidence managing asthma by family interview at baseline and at 12 or 24 months. Patient-centered and care-process outcomes included patient/parent assessment of quality of care and confidence in self-management, asthma action plan review, and documentation of guideline-based indicators of quality of care. Direct clinical outcomes included daytime and nighttime symptoms, use of rescue medications, acute care and emergency department visits, hospitalizations, and missed school days. Each clinic site's degree of adherence to the intervention model was evaluated and ranked to examine the correlation between model adherence and outcomes.
Cross-sectional data showed clinic-wide improvements in the documentation of asthma severity, review of action plans, health services use, and asthma symptoms. At follow-up in the longitudinal sample, fewer patients reported acute visits, emergency department visits, hospitalizations, frequent daytime and nighttime symptoms, and missed school days compared with baseline. More patients reported excellent or very good quality of care and confidence in asthma self-management. Linear regression analysis of the clinical sites' model adherence ranks against site-level combined scores estimating overall outcomes, clinical outcomes, and improvements in clinical care processes showed significant linear correlations with R2 > or = 0.60.
The demonstration produced major improvements in asthma-related care processes and clinical outcomes. Closer adherence to the demonstration model was directly associated with better outcomes.
本研究旨在通过采用基于团队的方法,运用持续质量改进并借助社区卫生工作者,改善经济条件不利的学龄儿童这一在种族和地理上存在差异的人群中与哮喘相关的健康结局。
开展了一项示范项目,涉及7家社区诊所,为约3000名5至18岁的哮喘儿童提供治疗。通过在基线期和24个月时进行随机横断面图表审查,评估哮喘诊所总体人群护理过程的变化(N = 560)。对患有中度或重度持续性哮喘或控制不佳的哮喘患者子集(N = 405)进行纵向随访,通过在基线期以及12或24个月时进行家庭访谈,了解特定的哮喘相关临床结局、护理满意度以及管理哮喘的信心。以患者为中心的护理过程结局包括患者/家长对护理质量的评估以及自我管理的信心、哮喘行动计划审查以及基于指南的护理质量指标记录。直接临床结局包括白天和夜间症状、急救药物使用、急性护理和急诊科就诊、住院以及缺课天数。评估并对每个诊所地点对干预模型的依从程度进行排名,以检查模型依从性与结局之间的相关性。
横断面数据显示,在哮喘严重程度记录、行动计划审查、卫生服务利用和哮喘症状方面,整个诊所均有改善。在纵向样本的随访中,与基线相比,报告急性就诊、急诊科就诊、住院、频繁白天和夜间症状以及缺课天数的患者减少。更多患者报告护理质量优秀或非常好,并且对哮喘自我管理有信心。对临床地点的模型依从排名与估计总体结局、临床结局以及临床护理过程改善的地点水平综合评分进行线性回归分析,显示出显著的线性相关性,R2≥0.60。
该示范项目在与哮喘相关的护理过程和临床结局方面取得了重大改善。更紧密地遵循示范模型与更好的结局直接相关。