Ignaciuk Adriana M, Sanders Johan
Environmental Economics and Natural Resources Group, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Biotechnol J. 2007 Dec;2(12):1535-46. doi: 10.1002/biot.200700125.
Due to more stringent energy and climate policies, it is expected that many traditional chemicals will be replaced by their biomass-based substitutes, bio-chemicals. These innovations, however, can influence land allocation since the demand for land dedicated to specific crops might increase. Moreover, it can have an influence on traditional agricultural production. In this paper, we use an applied general equilibrium framework, in which we include two different bio-refinery processes and incorporate so-called cascading mechanisms. The bio-refinery processes use grass, as one of the major inputs, to produce bio-nylon and propane-diol (1,3PDO) to substitute currently produced fossil fuel-based nylon and ethane-diol. We examine the impact of specific climate policies on the bioelectricity share in total electricity production, land allocation, and production quantities and prices of selected commodities. The novel technologies become competitive, with an increased stringency of climate policies. This switch, however, does not induce a higher share of bioelectricity. The cascade does stimulate the production of bioelectricity, but it induces more of a shift in inputs in the bioelectricity sector (from biomass to the cascaded bio-nylon and 1, 3PDO) than an increase in production level of bioelectricity. We conclude that dedicated biomass crops will remain the main option for bioelectricity production: the contribution of the biomass systems remains limited. Moreover, the bioelectricity sector looses a competition for land for biomass production with bio-refineries.
由于更为严格的能源和气候政策,预计许多传统化学品将被其基于生物质的替代品——生物化学品所取代。然而,这些创新可能会影响土地分配,因为对特定作物种植用地的需求可能会增加。此外,它还会对传统农业生产产生影响。在本文中,我们使用了一个应用一般均衡框架,其中包括两种不同的生物炼制过程,并纳入了所谓的级联机制。生物炼制过程以草作为主要投入之一,生产生物尼龙和丙二醇(1,3 - PDO),以替代目前生产的基于化石燃料的尼龙和乙二醇。我们研究了特定气候政策对生物电力在总电力生产中的份额、土地分配以及选定商品的产量和价格的影响。随着气候政策愈发严格,这些新技术变得具有竞争力。然而,这种转变并不会带来更高的生物电力份额。级联确实刺激了生物电力的生产,但它引发的更多是生物电力部门投入的转移(从生物质转向级联的生物尼龙和1,3 - PDO),而非生物电力生产水平的提高。我们得出结论,专用生物质作物仍将是生物电力生产的主要选择:生物质系统的贡献仍然有限。此外,生物电力部门在生物质生产用地方面输给了生物炼制厂。