Patel M K, Dornburg V, Hermann B G, Shen Li, van Overbeek Leo
Department of Science, Technology and Society, Utrecht University, The Netherlands.
Sheng Wu Gong Cheng Xue Bao. 2008 Dec;24(12):2022-6.
Practically all organic chemicals and plastics are nowadays produced from crude oil and natural gas. However, it is possible to produce a wide range of bulk chemicals from renewable resources by application of biotechnology. This paper focuses on White Biotechnology, which makes use of bacteria (or yeasts) or enzymes for the conversion of the fermentable sugar to the target product. It is shown that White Biotechnology offers substantial savings of non-renewable energy use and greenhouse gas emissions for nearly all of the products studied. Under favorable boundary conditions up to two thirds (67%) of the current non-renewable energy use for the production of the selected chemicals can be saved by 2050 if substantial technological progress is made and if the use of lignocellulosic feedstocks is successfully developed. The analysis for Europe (E.U. 25 countries) shows that land requirements related to White Biotechnology chemicals are not likely to become a critical issue in the next few decades, especially considering the large unused and underutilized resources in Eastern Europe. Substantial macroeconomic savings can be achieved under favourable boundary conditions. In principle, natural bacteria and enzymes can be used for White Biotechnology but, according to many experts in the fields, Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO) will be necessary in order to achieve the high yields, concentrations and productivities that are required to reach economic viability. Safe containment and inactivation of GMOs after release is very important because not all possible implications caused by the interaction of recombinant genes with other populations can be foreseen. If adequate precautionary measures are taken, the risks related to the use of genetically modified organisms in White Biotechnology are manageable. We conclude that the core requirements to be fulfilled in order to make clear steps towards a bio-based chemical industry are substantial technological progress in the bioprocess step and in downstream processing, high prices for fossil fuels and low prices for fermentable sugar. We strongly recommend to develop an integrated White Biotechnology strategy taking into account these four core requirements and other important accompanying activities.
如今,几乎所有的有机化学品和塑料都是由原油和天然气生产的。然而,通过应用生物技术,利用可再生资源生产多种大宗化学品是可行的。本文重点关注白色生物技术,它利用细菌(或酵母)或酶将可发酵糖转化为目标产品。研究表明,白色生物技术几乎为所有研究的产品大幅节省了不可再生能源的使用和温室气体排放。在有利的边界条件下,如果取得重大技术进步且成功开发木质纤维素原料的使用,到2050年,生产所选化学品目前使用的不可再生能源最多可节省三分之二(67%)。对欧洲(欧盟25国)的分析表明,与白色生物技术化学品相关的土地需求在未来几十年不太可能成为关键问题,尤其是考虑到东欧有大量未使用和未充分利用的资源。在有利的边界条件下可实现可观的宏观经济节省。原则上,天然细菌和酶可用于白色生物技术,但该领域的许多专家认为,为了实现经济可行性所需的高产量、高浓度和高生产率,转基因生物将是必要的。转基因生物释放后的安全封存和灭活非常重要,因为重组基因与其他种群相互作用所产生的所有可能影响并非都能预见。如果采取适当的预防措施,白色生物技术中使用转基因生物的相关风险是可控的。我们得出结论,要朝着生物基化学工业迈出明确步伐,需要满足的核心要求是生物过程步骤和下游加工方面的重大技术进步、化石燃料高价以及可发酵糖低价。我们强烈建议制定一项综合的白色生物技术战略,同时考虑这四个核心要求及其他重要的配套活动。