Hodgson David C, Koh Eng-Siew, Tran Tu Huan, Heydarian Mostafa, Tsang Richard, Pintilie Melania, Xu Tony, Huang Lei, Sachs Rainer K, Brenner David J
University of Toronto, Department of Radiation Oncology, Princess Margaret Hospital, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Cancer. 2007 Dec 1;110(11):2576-86. doi: 10.1002/cncr.23081.
Estimates of radiation-related second cancer risk among Hodgkin lymphoma survivors are largely based on radiation therapy (RT) fields and doses no longer in use, and these estimates do not account for differences in normal tissue dose among individual patients. This study gives individualized estimates for the risks of lung and female breast cancer expected with contemporary involved-field RT and low-dose (20 Gy) RT for mediastinal Hodgkin lymphoma.
Three RT plans were constructed for 37 consecutive patients with mediastinal Hodgkin lymphoma: 35 Gy mantle RT, 35 Gy involved-field RT (IFRT), and 20 Gy IFRT. For each of the 111 RT plans, individual-level dosimetry data were incorporated into a cell initiation/inactivation/proliferation model to estimate the excess relative risk (ERR) and cumulative incidence of radiation-induced second cancer.
ERR estimates were compatible with results of epidemiological studies. Compared with 35 Gy mantle radiation therapy, 35 Gy IFRT was predicted to reduce the 20-year ERRs of breast and lung cancer by 63% and 21%, respectively, primarily because of lower normal tissue doses with the omission of axillary RT. Low-dose (20 Gy) IFRT was associated with a 77% and 57% decrease in these ERRs. Patient-specific differences in normal tissue dose with IFRT led to 11-fold and 3.6-fold variations among individual's estimates of breast and lung cancer ERR, respectively.
Contemporary IFRT is predicted to substantially reduce risk of secondary breast and lung cancer compared with mantle RT, with considerable variation in risk among individuals. Individualized prospective risk estimates could facilitate patient-specific counseling and the development of more effective RT techniques.
霍奇金淋巴瘤幸存者辐射相关第二原发癌风险的估计主要基于已不再使用的放射治疗(RT)野和剂量,且这些估计未考虑个体患者正常组织剂量的差异。本研究给出了当代累及野RT和低剂量(20 Gy)RT治疗纵隔霍奇金淋巴瘤时预期的肺癌和女性乳腺癌风险的个体化估计。
为37例连续的纵隔霍奇金淋巴瘤患者构建了三种RT计划:35 Gy斗篷野RT、35 Gy累及野RT(IFRT)和20 Gy IFRT。对于111个RT计划中的每一个,将个体水平的剂量测定数据纳入细胞启动/失活/增殖模型,以估计辐射诱发第二原发癌的超额相对风险(ERR)和累积发病率。
ERR估计值与流行病学研究结果相符。与35 Gy斗篷野放射治疗相比,预计35 Gy IFRT可使乳腺癌和肺癌的20年ERR分别降低63%和21%,这主要是因为省略腋窝RT后正常组织剂量较低。低剂量(20 Gy)IFRT使这些ERR分别降低77%和57%。IFRT时正常组织剂量的患者特异性差异分别导致个体乳腺癌和肺癌ERR估计值有11倍和3.6倍的差异。
与斗篷野RT相比,预计当代IFRT可大幅降低继发乳腺癌和肺癌的风险,个体间风险差异较大。个体化的前瞻性风险估计有助于进行针对患者的咨询,并推动更有效的RT技术的发展。