Dawson T E, Jamison J
Liverpool Women's Hospital, Urogynaecology, Crown St, Liverpool, Merseyside, UK, L87SS.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2007 Oct 17(4):CD006113. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006113.pub2.
BACKGROUND: Painful Bladder Syndrome/Interstitial Cystitis (PBS/IC) occurs predominantly in women. It is a poorly-understood condition with symptoms of bladder pain, urinary frequency, urgency and nocturia. Treatments for PBS/IC include dietary/lifestyle interventions, oral medication, intravesical instillations and, in some cases, surgery. Success rates are generally modest and there is little consensus as to the best form of treatment for this condition. OBJECTIVES: To assess the effectiveness of intravesical treatment for PBS/IC. SEARCH STRATEGY: We searched the Cochrane Incontinence Group specialised trials register (30 May 2006) as well as reference lists of all selected trials. Recognised researchers in the field were contacted for any additional relevant material. SELECTION CRITERIA: Randomised or quasi-randomised controlled trials were included in the review if they had recruited participants with a clinical diagnosis of PBS/IC and if at least one arm of the trial was treatment with an intravesical preparation. Outcome measures were pre-determined, the primary ones being the effect on pain and bladder capacity. Others included symptomatic response to treatment, quality-of-life assessment, economic factors and adverse events. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: Two reviewers independently assessed trial eligibility and quality, then extracted relevant data from the studies. MAIN RESULTS: Nine eligible trials were identified - six parallel group, one incomplete cross-over and two cross-over trials - with a total of 616 participants. Six trials compared an 'active' instillation with placebo instillation, two compared different types of instillation, and one was a comparison of an instillation plus bladder training versus bladder training alone. Altogether, the review included trials of six different types of intravesical instillation: Resiniferatoxin, Dimethyl sulfoxide, BCG, pentosanpolysulphate, oxybutin, and alkalinisation of urine pH. Confidence intervals were generally wide. Resiniferatoxin was not associated with sustained differences in the review outcomes reported but pain during instillation and withdrawal from treatment was significantly more common. The data available about Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) were very limited but with no apparent differences from placebo. Groups treated with BCG tended to report less pain and fewer general symptoms. Although adverse events were commonly reported, these were no more common after BCG than after placebo instillation. The few data about Pentosanpolysulphate tended to favour the actively treated, but with wide confidence intervals; there was little information about adverse events. Oxybutinin instillation was associated with increased bladder capacity, reduced frequency, improved quality of life scores and fewer drop-outs. Alkalinisation of urine pH did not make any clear difference, but with potentially wide confidence intervals. AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: Overall, the evidence base for treating PBS/IC using intravesical preparations is limited and the potential for meta-analysis reduced by variation in the outcome measures used. The quality of trial reports was mixed and in some cases this precluded any meaningful data extraction. BCG and oxybutin are reasonably well-tolerated and evidence is most promising for these. Resiniferatoxin showed no evidence of effect for most outcomes and caused pain, which reduced treatment compliance. There is little evidence for the other treatments included in this review. Randomised controlled trials are still needed and study design should incorporate outcomes that are most relevant to these with PBS/IC and should be standardised.
背景:疼痛性膀胱综合征/间质性膀胱炎(PBS/IC)主要发生于女性。这是一种了解甚少的病症,症状包括膀胱疼痛、尿频、尿急和夜尿症。PBS/IC的治疗方法包括饮食/生活方式干预、口服药物、膀胱内灌注,在某些情况下还包括手术。成功率一般不高,对于该病症的最佳治疗方式也几乎没有共识。 目的:评估膀胱内治疗对PBS/IC的有效性。 检索策略:我们检索了Cochrane尿失禁小组专门试验注册库(2006年5月30日)以及所有入选试验的参考文献列表。还联系了该领域公认的研究人员以获取任何其他相关资料。 选择标准:如果随机或半随机对照试验招募了临床诊断为PBS/IC的参与者,并且试验的至少一个组采用膀胱内制剂进行治疗,则纳入本综述。预先确定了结局指标,主要指标是对疼痛和膀胱容量的影响。其他指标包括对治疗的症状反应、生活质量评估、经济因素和不良事件。 数据收集与分析:两名评价员独立评估试验的合格性和质量,然后从研究中提取相关数据。 主要结果:确定了9项合格试验——6项平行组试验、1项不完全交叉试验和2项交叉试验——共616名参与者。6项试验将“活性”灌注与安慰剂灌注进行比较,2项试验比较不同类型的灌注,1项试验比较灌注加膀胱训练与单纯膀胱训练。本综述总共纳入了6种不同类型膀胱内灌注的试验:辣椒素、二甲基亚砜、卡介苗、戊聚糖多硫酸盐、奥昔布宁以及尿液pH值碱化。置信区间通常较宽。辣椒素与所报告的综述结局持续差异无关,但灌注期间和撤药时的疼痛明显更常见。关于二甲基亚砜(DMSO)的可用数据非常有限,但与安慰剂无明显差异。接受卡介苗治疗的组往往报告疼痛较轻且一般症状较少。虽然不良事件普遍有报告,但卡介苗治疗后不良事件并不比安慰剂灌注后更常见。关于戊聚糖多硫酸盐的少量数据倾向于支持积极治疗组,但置信区间较宽;关于不良事件的信息很少。奥昔布宁灌注与膀胱容量增加、尿频减少、生活质量评分改善以及退出试验者减少有关。尿液pH值碱化没有明显差异,但置信区间可能较宽。 作者结论:总体而言,使用膀胱内制剂治疗PBS/IC的证据基础有限,且由于所使用的结局指标存在差异,进行荟萃分析的可能性降低。试验报告的质量参差不齐,在某些情况下这妨碍了任何有意义的数据提取。卡介苗和奥昔布宁耐受性较好,证据对这两种药物最有前景。辣椒素在大多数结局方面未显示出效果证据,且会引起疼痛,这降低了治疗依从性。本综述中纳入的其他治疗方法几乎没有证据支持。仍然需要随机对照试验,研究设计应纳入与PBS/IC最相关的结局指标,并应标准化。
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2007-10-17
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2018-2-6
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022-9-23
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2018-2-9
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2025-3-11
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022-6-22
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2018-7-9
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2005-7-20
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022-4-26
Int J Mol Sci. 2023-10-10
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020-7-30
Transl Androl Urol. 2015-12
Int Urogynecol J. 2012-9