Fasola Gianpiero, Belvedere Ornella, Aita Marianna, Zanin Tina, Follador Alessandro, Cassetti Paolo, Meduri Stefano, De Pangher Vincenzo, Pignata Giusto, Rosolen Valentina, Barbone Fabio, Grossi Francesco
Department of Medical Oncology, University Hospital of Udine, P.le S. M. Misericordia 15, 33100 Udine, Italy.
Oncologist. 2007 Oct;12(10):1215-24. doi: 10.1634/theoncologist.12-10-1215.
To evaluate the feasibility of using low-dose computed tomography (LDCT) for the early diagnosis of lung cancer and malignant pleural mesothelioma in an asbestos-exposed population.
Between February 2002 and October 2003, 1,045 volunteers already enrolled in a surveillance program for asbestos-exposed workers and former workers were recruited. The main eligibility criteria were: written informed consent, definite exposure to asbestos, age 40-75, no prior cancer or severe concomitant conditions, no chest CT scan in the past 2 years. A smoking history was not required. After a structured interview, chest X-ray (CXR) and LDCT were performed. Participants with negative examinations were assigned to annual LDCT. Participants with positive findings received high-resolution CT and additional diagnostic workup as appropriate.
Baseline characteristics of the screened population were: median asbestos exposure time, 30 years; median age, 58; median pack-years in smokers/former smokers, 18.5. Thirty-four percent had never smoked. On LDCT, 834 noncalcified nodules were identified in 44% of participants, versus 43 nodules in 4% on CXR. Pleural abnormalities were observed in 44% and 70% of participants by CXR and LDCT, respectively. Overall, LDCT identified nine cases of non-small cell lung cancer-eight stage I, one stage IIA-and one thymic carcinoid, corresponding to 1% of the enrolled population. All cases were radically treated. None had been detected by CXR. No pleural mesothelioma was diagnosed. There were 11 false-positive results.
Our findings first suggest that LDCT may be at least as useful in asbestos workers as in heavy smokers for the early diagnosis of lung cancer; this benefit is evident even in a poor-risk population, with low rates of smoking prevalence and a previous history of radiological surveillance. The role of spiral tomography in screening for pleural mesothelioma remains uncertain.
评估在石棉暴露人群中使用低剂量计算机断层扫描(LDCT)早期诊断肺癌和恶性胸膜间皮瘤的可行性。
在2002年2月至2003年10月期间,招募了1045名已参加石棉暴露工人和退休工人监测项目的志愿者。主要入选标准为:书面知情同意、明确的石棉暴露史、年龄40 - 75岁、无既往癌症或严重合并症、过去2年内未进行过胸部CT扫描。无需吸烟史。经过结构化访谈后,进行胸部X线(CXR)和LDCT检查。检查结果为阴性的参与者被安排每年进行LDCT检查。检查结果为阳性的参与者接受高分辨率CT检查,并根据情况进行额外的诊断性检查。
筛查人群的基线特征为:石棉暴露时间中位数为30年;年龄中位数为58岁;吸烟者/既往吸烟者的吸烟包年数中位数为18.5。34%的人从不吸烟。在LDCT检查中,44%的参与者发现了834个非钙化结节,而在CXR检查中,4%的参与者发现了43个结节。CXR和LDCT分别在44%和70%的参与者中观察到胸膜异常。总体而言,LDCT发现了9例非小细胞肺癌——8例I期,1例IIA期——以及1例胸腺类癌,占入选人群的1%。所有病例均接受了根治性治疗。CXR未检测到任何病例。未诊断出胸膜间皮瘤。有11例假阳性结果。
我们的研究结果首次表明,LDCT在石棉工人中对肺癌的早期诊断可能至少与重度吸烟者一样有用;即使在风险较低的人群中,吸烟率低且有放射学监测史,这种益处也很明显。螺旋断层扫描在胸膜间皮瘤筛查中的作用仍不确定。