Depypere Leander, Chaerle Peter, Mijnsbrugge Kristine Vander, Goetghebeur Paul
Ghent University, Department of Biology, Research Group Spermatophytes, K.L. Ledeganckstraat 35, B-9000 Gent, Belgium.
Ann Bot. 2007 Dec;100(7):1585-97. doi: 10.1093/aob/mcm260. Epub 2007 Oct 25.
Identification of Prunus groups at subspecies or variety level is complicated by the wide range of variation and morphological transitional states. Knowledge of the degree of variability within and between species is a sine qua non for taxonomists. Here, a detailed study of endocarp dimension and shape variation for taxa of Prunus section Prunus is presented.
The sample size necessary to obtain an estimation of the population mean with a precision of 5 % was determined by iteration. Two cases were considered: (1) the population represents an individual; and (2) the population represents a species. The intra-individual and intraspecific variation of Prunus endocarps was studied by analysing the coefficients of variance for dimension and shape parameters. Morphological variation among taxa was assessed using univariate statistics. The influence of the time of sampling and the level of hydration on endocarp dimensions and shape was examined by means of pairwise t-tests. In total, 14 endocarp characters were examined for five Eurasian plum taxa.
All linear measurements and index values showed a low or normal variability on the individual and species level. In contrast, the parameter 'Vertical Asymmetry' had high coefficients of variance for one or more of the taxa studied. Of all dimension and shape parameters studied, only 'Triangle' differed significantly between mature endocarps of P. insititia sampled with a time difference of 1 month. The level of hydration affected endocarp dimensions and shape significantly.
Index values and the parameters 'Perimeter', 'Area', 'Triangle', 'Ellipse', 'Circular' and 'Rectangular', based on sample sizes and coefficients of variance, were found to be most appropriate for further taxonomic analysis. However, use of one, single endocarp parameter is not satisfactory for discrimination between Eurasian plum taxa, mainly because of overlapping ranges. Before analysing dried endocarps, full hydration is recommended, as this restores the original dimensions and shape.
李属在亚种或变种水平上的分类鉴定因广泛的变异范围和形态过渡状态而变得复杂。了解物种内部和物种之间的变异程度是分类学家的必要条件。本文对李属李组植物的内果皮尺寸和形状变异进行了详细研究。
通过迭代确定以5%的精度估计总体均值所需的样本量。考虑了两种情况:(1)总体代表一个个体;(2)总体代表一个物种。通过分析尺寸和形状参数的方差系数,研究了李属内果皮的个体内和种内变异。使用单变量统计评估分类群之间的形态变异。通过配对t检验研究了采样时间和水合水平对内果皮尺寸和形状的影响。总共对5个欧亚李分类群的14个内果皮特征进行了研究。
所有线性测量值和指数值在个体和物种水平上均显示出低或正常的变异性。相比之下,参数“垂直不对称性”在所研究的一个或多个分类群中具有较高的方差系数。在所有研究的尺寸和形状参数中,只有“三角形”在采样时间相差1个月的欧洲李成熟内果皮之间存在显著差异。水合水平对内果皮尺寸和形状有显著影响。
基于样本量和方差系数,指数值以及参数“周长”“面积”“三角形”“椭圆形”“圆形”和“矩形”被认为最适合进一步的分类分析。然而,使用单个内果皮参数不足以区分欧亚李分类群,主要是因为范围重叠。在分析干燥的内果皮之前,建议充分水合,因为这可以恢复其原始尺寸和形状。