Vairo Giampietro L, Myers Joseph B, Sell Timothy C, Fu Freddie H, Harner Christopher D, Lephart Scott M
Department of Kinesiology, Athletic Training Research Laboratory, College of Health and Human Development, The Pennsylvania State University, 146 Recreation Building, University Park, PA 16802, USA.
Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2008 Jan;16(1):2-14. doi: 10.1007/s00167-007-0427-4. Epub 2007 Nov 1.
The hamstrings musculature is a vital component of an intricate dynamic knee joint restraint mechanism. However, there is evidence based on research studies suggesting potential deficits to this complex mechanism due to donor site morbidity resulting from harvest of the ipsilateral semitendinosus and gracilis autograft (ISGA) for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). The purpose of this retrospective research study was to investigate the effects of ISGA ACLR on neuromuscular and biomechanical performance during a single-leg vertical drop landing (VDL), a functional task and associated mechanism of anterior cruciate ligament disruption during physical activity. Fourteen physically active participants 22.5 +/- 4.1 years of age and 21.4 +/- 10.7 months post ISGA ACLR underwent bilateral neuromuscular, biomechanical and isokinetic strength and endurance evaluations matched to 14 control participants by sex, age, height and mass. Kinetic and kinematic data was obtained with 3-D motion analyses utilizing inverse dynamics while performing single-leg VDLs from a height of 30 cm. Integrated surface electromyography (SEMG) assessments of the quadriceps, hamstrings and gastrocnemius musculature were also conducted. Additionally, knee joint flexion strength (60 degrees s(-1)) and endurance (240 degrees s(-1)) measurements were tested via isokinetic dynamometry. No significant differences existed in hip and net summated extensor moments within or between groups. The ISGA ACLR participants recorded significantly decreased peak vertical ground reaction force (VGRF) landing upon the involved lower extremity compared to uninvolved (P = 0.028) and matched (P < 0.0001) controls. Participants having undergone ISGA ACLR also displayed greater peak hip joint flexion angles landing upon the involved lower extremity compared to uninvolved (P = 0.020) and matched (P = 0.026) controls at initial ground contact. The ISGA ACLR group furthermore exhibited increased peak hip joint flexion angles landing upon the involved lower extremity compared to uninvolved (P = 0.019) and matched (P = 0.007) controls at peak VGRF. Moreover, ISGA ALCR participants demonstrated greater peak knee (P = 0.005) and ankle (P = 0.017) joint flexion angles when landing upon the involved lower extremity compared to the matched control at peak VGRF. The ISGA ACLR group produced significantly greater reactive muscle activation of the vastus medialis (P = 0.013), vastus lateralis (P = 0.008) and medial hamstrings (P = 0.024) in the involved lower extremity compared to the matched control. The ISGA ACLR participants also exhibited greater preparatory (P = 0.033) and reactive (P = 0.022) co-contraction muscle activity of the quadriceps and hamstrings landing upon the involved lower extremity compared to the matched control. In addition, the ISGA ACLR group produced significantly less preparatory (P = 0.005) and reactive (P = 0.010) muscle activation of the gastrocnemius in the involved lower extremity compared to the uninvolved control. No significant differences were present in hamstrings muscular strength and endurance. Harvest of the ISGA for purposes of ACLR does not appear to result in significant neuromuscular, biomechanical or strength and endurance deficiencies due to donor site morbidity. However, it is evident that this specific population exhibits unique neuromuscular and biomechanical adaptations aimed to stabilize the knee previously subjected to ACL trauma and safeguard the ISGA ACLR joint. Co-contraction of quadriceps and hamstrings as well as inhibition of gastrocnemius muscle activation may serve to moderate excessive loads exposed to the intra-articular ISGA during single-leg VDLs. Furthermore, greater muscle activation of the hamstrings in conjunction with increased peak hip, knee and ankle joint flexion angles may assist in enhancing acceptance of VGRF transferred through the kinetic chain following single-leg VDLs.
腘绳肌是复杂的动态膝关节约束机制的重要组成部分。然而,基于研究的证据表明,由于在前交叉韧带重建(ACLR)中采用同侧半腱肌和股薄肌自体移植(ISGA)导致供体部位发病,这种复杂机制可能存在潜在缺陷。这项回顾性研究的目的是调查ISGA ACLR对单腿垂直下落着陆(VDL)期间神经肌肉和生物力学性能的影响,VDL是一项功能任务,也是体育活动中前交叉韧带断裂的相关机制。14名身体活跃的参与者,年龄22.5±4.1岁,在ISGA ACLR后21.4±10.7个月,接受了双侧神经肌肉、生物力学以及等速肌力和耐力评估,并按照性别、年龄、身高和体重与14名对照参与者进行匹配。在从30厘米高度进行单腿VDL时,利用逆动力学通过三维运动分析获取动力学和运动学数据。还对股四头肌、腘绳肌和腓肠肌进行了表面肌电图(SEMG)综合评估。此外,通过等速测力法测试了膝关节屈曲力量(60度/秒)和耐力(240度/秒)。组内或组间的髋关节和净总伸肌力矩没有显著差异。与未受累(P = 0.028)和匹配(P < 0.0001)的对照组相比,ISGA ACLR参与者在受累下肢着陆时记录到的垂直地面反作用力(VGRF)峰值显著降低。与未受累(P = 0.020)和匹配(P = 0.026)的对照组相比,接受ISGA ACLR的参与者在初始地面接触时,受累下肢着陆时的髋关节屈曲峰值角度也更大。此外,与未受累(P = 0.019)和匹配(P = 0.007)的对照组相比,ISGA ACLR组在VGRF峰值时,受累下肢着陆时的髋关节屈曲峰值角度也增加。此外,与匹配对照组相比,ISGA ALCR参与者在VGRF峰值时,受累下肢着陆时的膝关节(P = 0.005)和踝关节(P = 0.017)屈曲峰值角度更大。与匹配对照组相比,ISGA ACLR组受累下肢的股内侧肌(P = 0.013)、股外侧肌(P = 0.008)和腘绳肌内侧头(P = 0.024)的反应性肌肉激活显著更大。与匹配对照组相比,ISGA ACLR参与者在受累下肢着陆时,股四头肌和腘绳肌的预备性(P = 0.033)和反应性(P = 0.022)共同收缩肌肉活动也更大。此外,与未受累对照组相比,ISGA ACLR组受累下肢的腓肠肌预备性(P = 0.005)和反应性(P = 0.010)肌肉激活显著更少。腘绳肌的肌肉力量和耐力没有显著差异。为ACLR目的进行ISGA采集似乎不会因供体部位发病而导致显著的神经肌肉、生物力学或力量和耐力缺陷。然而,很明显,这一特定人群表现出独特的神经肌肉和生物力学适应性,旨在稳定先前遭受ACL创伤的膝关节并保护ISGA ACLR关节。股四头肌和腘绳肌的共同收缩以及腓肠肌肌肉激活的抑制可能有助于减轻单腿VDL期间关节内ISGA所承受的过大负荷。此外,腘绳肌更大的肌肉激活与髋关节、膝关节和踝关节屈曲峰值角度的增加相结合,可能有助于增强单腿VDL后通过动力链传递的VGRF的接受度。