Hyder Adnan A, Bloom Gerald, Leach Melissa, Syed Shamsuzzoha B, Peters David H
BMC Public Health. 2007 Oct 31;7:309. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-7-309.
The interface between research and policymaking in low-income countries is highly complex. The ability of health systems research to influence policy processes in such settings face numerous challenges. Successful analysis of the research-policy interface in these settings requires understanding of contextual factors as well as key influences on the interface. Future Health Systems (FHS): Innovations for Equity is a consortium conducting research in six countries in Asia and Africa. One of the three cross-country research themes of the consortium is analysis of the relationship between research (evidence) and policy making, especially their impact on the poor; insights gained in the initial conceptual phase of FHS activities can inform the global knowledge pool on this subject.
This paper provides a review of the research-policy interface in low-income countries and proposes a conceptual framework, followed by directions for empirical approaches. First, four developmental perspectives are considered: social institutional factors; virtual versus grassroots realities; science-society relationships; and construction of social arrangements. Building on these developmental perspectives three research-policy interface entry points are identified: 1. Recognizing policy as complex processes; 2. Engaging key stakeholders: decision-makers, providers, scientists, and communities; and 3. Enhancing accountability. A conceptual framework with three entry points to the research-policy interface - policy processes; stakeholder interests, values, and power; and accountability - within a context provided by four developmental perspectives is proposed. Potential empirical approaches to the research-policy interface are then reviewed. Finally, the value of such innovative empirical analysis is considered.
The purpose of this paper is to provide the background, conceptual framework, and key research directions for empirical activities focused on the research-policy interface in low income settings. The interface can be strengthened through such analysis leading to potential improvements in population health in low-income settings. Health system development cognizant of the myriad factors at the research-policy interface can form the basis for innovative future health systems.
低收入国家的研究与政策制定之间的联系极为复杂。卫生系统研究在这些环境中影响政策进程的能力面临众多挑战。要成功分析这些环境中的研究 - 政策联系,需要了解背景因素以及对该联系的关键影响。未来卫生系统(FHS):公平创新是一个在亚洲和非洲六个国家开展研究的联盟。该联盟的三个跨国研究主题之一是分析研究(证据)与政策制定之间的关系,特别是它们对穷人的影响;在FHS活动的初始概念阶段获得的见解可为关于这一主题的全球知识库提供信息。
本文对低收入国家的研究 - 政策联系进行了综述,并提出了一个概念框架,随后给出了实证方法的方向。首先,考虑了四个发展视角:社会制度因素;虚拟与基层现实;科学与社会关系;以及社会安排的构建。基于这些发展视角,确定了三个研究 - 政策联系切入点:1. 将政策视为复杂过程;2. 让关键利益相关者参与:决策者、提供者、科学家和社区;3. 加强问责制。提出了一个概念框架,在四个发展视角提供的背景下,有三个研究 - 政策联系切入点——政策过程;利益相关者的利益、价值观和权力;以及问责制。然后回顾了研究 - 政策联系的潜在实证方法。最后,考虑了这种创新实证分析的价值。
本文的目的是为关注低收入环境中研究 - 政策联系的实证活动提供背景、概念框架和关键研究方向。通过这种分析可以加强这种联系,从而可能改善低收入环境中的人群健康。认识到研究 - 政策联系中众多因素的卫生系统发展可为未来创新的卫生系统奠定基础。