Patel Naresh P, Wolcott W Putnam, Johnson J Patrick, Cambron Helen, Lewin Marcial, McBride Duncan, Batzdorf Ulrich
Department of Neurological Surgical, Mayo Clinic Arizona, Phoenix, AZ 85054, USA.
Surg Neurol. 2008 Jan;69(1):20-4; discission 24. doi: 10.1016/j.surneu.2007.05.006. Epub 2007 Oct 31.
Anterior cervical spinal surgery has been used to treat a variety of conditions including spondylosis, fracture, tumor, infection, trauma, and instability. Esophageal perforation, a rare and unusual complication of anterior cervical procedures, has been largely relegated to only incidental case reports with few large retrospective studies performed to determine true incidence, treatment, etiology, and outcome.
More than 3000 anterior cervical spine surgeries conducted over a 30-year period by 5 active practicing surgeons were reviewed. There were 3 cases of esophageal injury identified with subsequent critical evaluation to determine presentation, diagnosis, risk factors, management, and outcomes. In addition, incidence rates were calculated based on overall occurrence and antecedent risk factors.
Two of the patients with esophageal injury had predisposing risk factors, including diverticula or cervical spine trauma. The third patient had no antecedent risk factors. Symptoms included axial spine pain, odynophagia, dysphagia, purulent spondylitis, and sepsis. Treatment consisted of one or more of the following: reoperation with exploration and repair, esophageal diversion, esophageal rest, antibiotic administration, and wound drainage. Functional outcomes were achieved in all cases with no deaths.
Esophageal injury incidence based on overall occurrence in this study was 0.1%. Patients with no antecedent risk factors had an incidence of 0.03%. Our results compare favorably with those of the Cervical Spine Research Society survey from 1989, which predicted an incidence of 0.25% based on questionnaires filed by surgeons, representing 1 of only 2 reports that included more than 1000 patients.
颈椎前路手术已被用于治疗多种病症,包括颈椎病、骨折、肿瘤、感染、创伤和不稳定。食管穿孔是颈椎前路手术一种罕见且不常见的并发症,在很大程度上仅见于偶然的病例报告,很少有大型回顾性研究来确定其真实发病率、治疗方法、病因及预后。
回顾了5位在职外科医生在30年期间进行的3000多例颈椎前路手术。确定了3例食管损伤病例,并随后进行了严格评估以确定其表现、诊断、危险因素、处理方法及预后。此外,根据总体发生率及先前的危险因素计算了发病率。
2例食管损伤患者有易感危险因素,包括憩室或颈椎创伤。第3例患者无先前危险因素。症状包括脊柱轴向疼痛、吞咽痛、吞咽困难、脓性脊柱炎和脓毒症。治疗包括以下一项或多项:再次手术探查并修复、食管改道、食管休息、给予抗生素及伤口引流。所有病例均取得了功能预后,无死亡病例。
基于本研究总体发生率的食管损伤发病率为0.1%。无先前危险因素的患者发病率为0.03%。我们的结果与1989年颈椎研究协会调查结果相比更优,该调查根据外科医生提交的问卷预测发病率为0.25%,是仅有的2篇纳入超过1000例患者的报告之一。