Dardenne Benoit, Dumont Muriel, Bollier Thierry
Department of Cognitive Sciences, University of Liège, Liège, Belgium.
J Pers Soc Psychol. 2007 Nov;93(5):764-79. doi: 10.1037/0022-3514.93.5.764.
Four experiments found benevolent sexism to be worse than hostile sexism for women's cognitive performance. Experiments 1-2 showed effects of paternalist benevolent sexism and ruled out explanations of perceived sexism, context pleasantness, and performance motivation. Experiment 3 showed effects of both paternalist and complementary gender differentiation components of benevolent sexism. Benevolent sexism per se (rather than the provision of unsolicited help involved in paternalism) worsened performance. Experiment 4 showed that impaired performance due to benevolent sexism was fully mediated by the mental intrusions women experienced about their sense of competence. Additionally, Experiment 4 showed that gender identification protected against hostile but not benevolent sexism. Despite the apparently positive and inoffensive tone of benevolent sexism, our research emphasizes its insidious dangers.
四项实验发现,善意性别歧视对女性认知表现的负面影响比敌意性别歧视更严重。实验1-2展示了家长式善意性别歧视的影响,并排除了对感知到的性别歧视、环境愉悦度和表现动机的解释。实验3展示了善意性别歧视中家长式和互补性性别分化成分的影响。善意性别歧视本身(而非家长式作风中主动提供的帮助)会降低表现。实验4表明,善意性别歧视导致的表现受损完全由女性对自身能力感的心理侵扰所介导。此外,实验4表明,性别认同能抵御敌意性别歧视,但不能抵御善意性别歧视。尽管善意性别歧视表面上具有积极且无害的语气,但我们的研究强调了其潜在的危害。