Lamendella Regina, Santo Domingo Jorge W, Kelty Catherine, Oerther Daniel B
Department of Environmental Engineering, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio 45220, USA.
Appl Environ Microbiol. 2008 Feb;74(3):575-84. doi: 10.1128/AEM.01221-07. Epub 2007 Nov 9.
Bifidobacteria have been recommended as potential indicators of human fecal pollution in surface waters even though very little is known about their presence in nonhuman fecal sources. The objective of this research was to shed light on the occurrence and molecular diversity of this fecal indicator group in different animals and environmental waters. Genus- and species-specific 16S rRNA gene PCR assays were used to study the presence of bifidobacteria among 269 fecal DNA extracts from 32 different animals. Twelve samples from three wastewater treatment plants and 34 water samples from two fecally impacted watersheds were also tested. The species-specific assays showed that Bifidobacterium adolescentis, B. bifidum, B. dentium, and B. catenulatum had the broadest host distribution (11.9 to 17.4%), whereas B. breve, B. infantis, and B. longum were detected in fewer than 3% of all fecal samples. Phylogenetic analysis of 356 bifidobacterial clones obtained from different animal feces showed that ca. 67% of all of the sequences clustered with cultured bifidobacteria, while the rest formed a supercluster with low sequence identity (i.e., <94%) to previously described Bifidobacterium spp. The B. pseudolongum subcluster (>97% similarity) contained 53 fecal sequences from seven different animal hosts, suggesting the cosmopolitan distribution of members of this clade. In contrast, two clades containing B. thermophilum and B. boum clustered exclusively with 37 and 18 pig fecal clones, respectively, suggesting host specificity. Using species-specific assays, bifidobacteria were detected in only two of the surface water DNA extracts, although other fecal anaerobic bacteria were detected in these waters. Overall, the results suggest that the use of bifidobacterial species as potential markers to monitor human fecal pollution in natural waters may be questionable.
双歧杆菌已被推荐作为地表水中人类粪便污染的潜在指示菌,尽管对于它们在非人类粪便来源中的存在情况知之甚少。本研究的目的是阐明这一粪便指示菌群在不同动物和环境水体中的发生情况及分子多样性。采用属特异性和种特异性16S rRNA基因PCR分析方法,研究了来自32种不同动物的269份粪便DNA提取物中双歧杆菌的存在情况。还对来自三个污水处理厂的12份样品以及来自两个受粪便污染流域的34份水样进行了检测。种特异性分析表明,青春双歧杆菌、两歧双歧杆菌、齿双歧杆菌和链状双歧杆菌具有最广泛的宿主分布(11.9%至17.4%),而短双歧杆菌、婴儿双歧杆菌和长双歧杆菌在所有粪便样本中的检出率均低于3%。对从不同动物粪便中获得的356个双歧杆菌克隆进行系统发育分析表明,约67%的序列与培养的双歧杆菌聚类,其余序列形成一个超级聚类,与先前描述的双歧杆菌属物种的序列同一性较低(即<94%)。假长双歧杆菌亚聚类(相似度>97%)包含来自七个不同动物宿主的53条粪便序列,表明该进化枝成员具有世界性分布。相比之下,包含嗜热双歧杆菌和布氏双歧杆菌的两个进化枝分别仅与37个和18个猪粪便克隆聚类,表明具有宿主特异性。使用种特异性分析方法,仅在两份地表水DNA提取物中检测到双歧杆菌,尽管在这些水体中检测到了其他粪便厌氧菌。总体而言,结果表明,将双歧杆菌物种用作监测天然水体中人类粪便污染的潜在标志物可能存在问题。