Dowsett Mitch, Goldhirsch Aron, Hayes Daniel F, Senn Hans-Joerg, Wood William, Viale Giuseppe
Academic Department of Biochemistry, Royal Marsden Hospital, London SW3 6JJ, UK.
Breast Cancer Res. 2007;9(6):R81. doi: 10.1186/bcr1798.
Large numbers of translational breast cancer research topics have been completed or are underway, but they differ widely in their immediate and/or future importance to clinical management. We therefore conducted an international Web-based consultation of breast cancer professionals to identify the topics most widely considered to be of highest priority.
Potential participants were contacted via two large e-mail databases and asked to register, at a Web site, the issues that they felt to be of highest priority. Four hundred nine questions were reduced by a steering committee to 70 unique issues, and registrants were asked to select the 6 questions they considered to be the most important.
Votes were recorded from 420 voters (2,520 votes) from 48 countries, with 48% of voters coming from North America. Half of the voters identified themselves as clinicians, with the remainder being academics, research scientists, or pathologists. The highest priority was to identify molecular signatures to select patients who could be spared chemotherapy, which gained about 50% more votes than the second topic and was consistently voted top by voters in North America, Europe, and the rest of the world. Research scientists voted the determination of the role of stem cells in breast cancer development, progression, and treatment sensitivity as the most important issue, but this was considered the sixth priority for clinicians and fourth overall.
This exercise may bring a greater focus of research resources onto issues voted as top priorities.
大量乳腺癌转化研究课题已经完成或正在进行中,但它们对临床管理的当前和/或未来重要性差异很大。因此,我们开展了一项针对乳腺癌专业人士的基于网络的国际咨询,以确定被广泛认为是最优先的课题。
通过两个大型电子邮件数据库联系潜在参与者,并要求他们在一个网站上登记他们认为最优先的问题。指导委员会将409个问题减少到70个独特问题,并要求登记者选择他们认为最重要的6个问题。
来自48个国家的420名投票者(共2520票)进行了投票,48%的投票者来自北美。一半的投票者表明自己是临床医生,其余为学者、研究科学家或病理学家。最优先的是确定分子特征以选择可免于化疗的患者,该问题获得的票数比第二个课题多约50%,并且在北美、欧洲和世界其他地区的投票者中一直被选为首要课题。研究科学家将确定干细胞在乳腺癌发生、发展和治疗敏感性中的作用选为最重要的问题,但临床医生认为这是第六优先事项,总体上是第四优先事项。
这项活动可能会使研究资源更多地集中在被选为优先事项的问题上。