Zhang Li-jun, Shin Eun Sim, Yu Zhong-xing, Li Shi-bo
Department of Pediatrics, University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, OK 73104, USA.
Chin Med J (Engl). 2007 Nov 20;120(22):2002-5.
There has been continuous debate as to whether Y chromosome loss is an age related phenomenon or a cytogenetic marker indicating a malignant change. This study aimed to investigate the frequency of Y chromosome loss in the specific patients in order to determine whether it is an age related phenomena or a cytogenetic marker indicating a malignant change.
Five hundred and ninety-two male patients with a median age of 59 years old (22 - 95 years) were included in this study. These patients were divided into two groups: the study group, including 237 patients who had hematological disorders included myeloproliferative disorder (MPD), myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS), acute myeloid leukemia (AML), chronic myeloid leukemia (CML), multiple myeloma (MM), and lymphoma and the control group including 355 patients with no evidence of hematological disease. Both conventional cytogenetics and fluorescence in situ hybridization using DNA probes specific for the centromere of chromosomes X or Y were performed according to our standard laboratory protocols.
Twenty-four out of 237 patients with hematological disorders (10.1%) had Y chromosome loss. Of these 24 patients, 2 patients had AML (5.0% of all AML patients), 2 patients had CML (5.7% of all CML patients), 2 patients had MPD (8.0% of all MPD patients), 3 patients had MM (10.0% of all MM patients), 5 patients had lymphoma (10.6% of all lymphoma patients) and 10 patients had MDS (16.7% of all MDS patients). Twenty-one out of these 24 patients had a loss of Y chromosome as the sole anomaly and the remaining three had a loss of Y chromosome accompanied with other structural changes detected by conventional cytogenetic analysis. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis confirmed the routine cytogenetic results. All 24 patients had a loss of Y chromosome with a range of 17.5% - 98.5% of cells. Two of the patients, one with AML and another with CML, had karyotype and FISH testing done both at the initial diagnosis and during remission. The results showed a loss of Y chromosome at initial diagnosis but a normal 46, XY karyotype during remission. Only 9 out of 355 patients (2.5%) without evidence of hematological disease had Y chromosome loss, among them 7 patients had cardiovascular diseases and 2 patients had kidney diseases. Comparison of the incidence of Y chromosome loss in patients with hematological disorders or without evidence of hematological disease using statistical analysis showed a statistically significance difference (P < 0.05).
The present study demonstrated that the frequency of Y chromosome loss is significantly higher in patients with hematological disorders than in patients without hematological disorders, which indicates that the loss of Y chromosome is associated with a neoplastic change.
关于Y染色体缺失是与年龄相关的现象还是指示恶性变化的细胞遗传学标志物,一直存在持续的争论。本研究旨在调查特定患者中Y染色体缺失的频率,以确定它是与年龄相关的现象还是指示恶性变化的细胞遗传学标志物。
本研究纳入了592例男性患者,中位年龄为59岁(22 - 95岁)。这些患者被分为两组:研究组,包括237例患有血液系统疾病的患者,其中有骨髓增殖性疾病(MPD)、骨髓增生异常综合征(MDS)、急性髓系白血病(AML)、慢性髓系白血病(CML)、多发性骨髓瘤(MM)和淋巴瘤;对照组包括355例无血液系统疾病证据的患者。根据我们的标准实验室方案,进行了常规细胞遗传学和使用针对X或Y染色体着丝粒的DNA探针的荧光原位杂交。
237例血液系统疾病患者中有24例(10.1%)出现Y染色体缺失。在这24例患者中,2例患有AML(占所有AML患者的5.0%),2例患有CML(占所有CML患者的5.7%),2例患有MPD(占所有MPD患者的8.0%),3例患有MM(占所有MM患者的10.0%),5例患有淋巴瘤(占所有淋巴瘤患者的10.6%),10例患有MDS(占所有MDS患者的16.7%)。这24例患者中有21例Y染色体缺失是唯一的异常,其余3例Y染色体缺失伴有常规细胞遗传学分析检测到的其他结构变化。荧光原位杂交(FISH)分析证实了常规细胞遗传学结果。所有24例患者均有Y染色体缺失,缺失细胞的比例在17.5% - 98.5%之间。其中2例患者,1例患有AML,另1例患有CML,在初诊时和缓解期均进行了核型和FISH检测。结果显示初诊时Y染色体缺失,但缓解期核型为正常的46, XY。在355例无血液系统疾病证据的患者中,只有9例(2.5%)出现Y染色体缺失,其中7例患有心血管疾病,2例患有肾脏疾病。使用统计分析比较血液系统疾病患者和无血液系统疾病证据患者中Y染色体缺失的发生率,显示有统计学显著差异(P < 0.05)。
本研究表明,血液系统疾病患者中Y染色体缺失的频率显著高于无血液系统疾病的患者,这表明Y染色体缺失与肿瘤性变化有关。