Crowther Kenneth G, Haimes Yacov Y, Taub Gideon
Center for Risk Management of Engineering Systems, Department of Systems and Information Engineering, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA, USA.
Risk Anal. 2007 Oct;27(5):1345-64. doi: 10.1111/j.1539-6924.2007.00965.x.
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has mandated all regions to "carefully weigh the benefit of each homeland security endeavor and only allocate resources where the benefit of reducing risk is worth the amount of additional cost" (DHS, 2006, p. 64). This mandate illuminates the need to develop methods for systemic valuation of preparedness measures that support strategic decision making. This article proposes an analysis method that naturally emerges from the structure of the inoperability input-output model (IIM) through which various regional- and sector-specific impact analyses can be cost-effectively integrated for natural and man-made disasters. The IIM is described extensively in a companion paper (Lian et al., 2007). Its reliance on data classifications structured by the U.S. Census Bureau and its extensive accounting of economic interdependencies enables us to decompose a risk analysis activity, perform independent assessments, and properly integrate the assessment for a systemic valuation of risk and risk management activity. In this article, we account for and assess some of the major impacts of Hurricanes Katrina and Rita to demonstrate this use of the IIM and illustrate hypothetical, reduced impacts resulting from various strategic preparedness decisions. Our results indicate the capability of the IIM to guide the decision-making processes involved in developing a preparedness strategy.
美国国土安全部(DHS)已要求所有地区“仔细权衡每项国土安全工作的效益,仅在降低风险的效益值得额外成本的情况下才分配资源”(国土安全部,2006年,第64页)。这一要求凸显了开发用于系统评估支持战略决策的备灾措施的方法的必要性。本文提出了一种分析方法,该方法自然地源于不可用性投入产出模型(IIM)的结构,通过该模型,可以对自然和人为灾害的各种区域和部门特定影响分析进行成本效益整合。在一篇配套论文中对IIM进行了广泛描述(Lian等人,2007年)。它依赖于美国人口普查局构建的数据分类以及对经济相互依存关系的广泛核算,这使我们能够分解风险分析活动、进行独立评估,并适当地整合评估以对风险和风险管理活动进行系统评估。在本文中,我们考虑并评估了卡特里娜飓风和丽塔飓风的一些主要影响,以展示IIM的这种用途,并说明各种战略备灾决策导致的假设性、减少的影响。我们的结果表明IIM有能力指导制定备灾战略所涉及的决策过程。