Abou-Jaoude Peter M, Zeitouni Anthony G, Soualmi Labib, Leblanc Richard
Department of Otolaryngology, McGill University Health Centre, Montreal, QC, Canada.
J Otolaryngol. 2007 Dec;36(6):322-6.
The surgical management of pituitary tumours is being impacted by the development of two key technologies: image guidance and endoscopy. This study sought to assess their impact.
Retrospective review of all patients referred to the Skull Base Clinic of the McGill University Health Centre since 2000. Patients were operated on in a multidisciplinary context using a multimodal approach combining endoscopy and microscopy. Imaging during the surgery was initially supported by both three-dimensional neuronavigation and traditional C-arm fluoroscopy.
Seventy-five patients were referred to the multidisciplinary clinic, for a total of 41 surgeries. Neuronavigation was used in all cases. C-arm fluoroscopy was not found to improve our surgeries and was removed from our protocol. Endoscopy was found to be advantageous as it allowed improved visualization. It also permitted identifying surrounding structures in the lateral wall of the sphenoid sinus, next to the tumour, and "around corners." Moreover, it encouraged multidisciplinary co-operation as it allowed neurosurgeons and otolaryngologists to follow progress during the case. Nevertheless, the microscope continued to play a role as it facilitated a bimanual technique, stable magnification, and a three-dimensional view. Morbidities in our case series appeared to be minimal.
Both endoscopy and the microscope were found to have a role in our surgeries. We consider these technologies to be complementary. C-arm fluoroscopy was rendered obsolete by the neuronavigation unit. A multidisciplinary, multimodal approach maximizes the benefits of these new technologies and permits the best surgical result.
两种关键技术——影像引导和内镜检查的发展正在影响垂体肿瘤的外科治疗。本研究旨在评估它们的影响。
回顾性分析自2000年以来转诊至麦吉尔大学健康中心颅底诊所的所有患者。患者在多学科背景下接受手术,采用内镜检查和显微镜检查相结合的多模式方法。手术期间的成像最初由三维神经导航和传统C形臂荧光透视支持。
75例患者转诊至多学科诊所,共进行了41次手术。所有病例均使用了神经导航。未发现C形臂荧光透视能改善我们的手术效果,因此已从我们的方案中移除。发现内镜检查具有优势,因为它能改善可视化效果。它还能识别蝶窦侧壁、肿瘤旁以及“拐角处”的周围结构。此外,它促进了多学科合作,因为它能让神经外科医生和耳鼻喉科医生在手术过程中了解进展情况。然而,显微镜仍发挥着作用,因为它便于双手操作技术、稳定放大以及提供三维视野。我们病例系列中的发病率似乎很低。
发现内镜检查和显微镜在我们的手术中都发挥了作用。我们认为这些技术是互补的。神经导航设备使C形臂荧光透视过时。多学科、多模式方法最大限度地发挥了这些新技术的优势,并能实现最佳手术效果。