Shimoni Zvi, Averbuch Yael, Shir Esther, Gottshalk Tzippi, Kfir Dalia, Niven Mark, Moshkowitz Menachem, Froom Paul
Internal Medicine B, Tel Aviv University, Ramat Aviv, Israel.
J Clin Gastroenterol. 2007 Nov-Dec;41(10):901-5. doi: 10.1097/01.mcg.0000225662.23179.b6.
To determine if feeds high in fiber continuously administered might minimize diarrhea.
The addition of soluble fiber to enteral feedings has not consistently decreased diarrhea in controlled clinical trials, and the effect of the use of intermittent or continuous infusions on the rate of diarrhea is similarly controversial.
We studied 148 of 160 selected elderly well-nourished patients with acute disease prohibiting oral intake in a controlled clinical trial in the setting of an internal medicine departments in a regional hospital who were divided into 4 groups and fed according to combinations of intermittent or continuous systems, with fiber-free or fiber rich formulas. The 5-day rate of diarrhea was defined as 2 liquid stools or 3 or more semisolid or liquid bowel movements during a 24-hour period. Other outcome variables included mortality, hospital days, prolonged hospitalization (over 20 d), fever, and stools positive for Clostridium difficile cytotoxin A/B.
The increased relative risk of the continuous/fiber-free, intermittent/fiber, and intermittent/fiber-free groups compared with the continuous/fiber group was 2.8 [95% confidence interval (CI)=1.0-8.1], 2.5 (95% CI=0.9-7.1), and 5.0 (95% CI=1.9-13.2), respectively. These findings were independent of age (>80 y), female sex, being treated with antibiotics for respiratory or urinary infections, receiving respiratory support, or being fully conscious. There were no significant differences in the other outcomes.
We conclude that in elderly well-nourished hospitalized patients with acute diseases prohibiting oral intake, continuous and closed enteral feedings with the addition of fiber is effective in reducing the rate of diarrhea.
确定持续给予高纤维喂养是否可使腹泻减至最少。
在对照临床试验中,向肠内喂养添加可溶性纤维未能始终如一地减少腹泻,并且间歇性或持续性输注的使用对腹泻发生率的影响同样存在争议。
我们在一家地区医院内科病房进行的一项对照临床试验中,研究了160例选定的营养良好的老年急性病患者中的148例,这些患者因疾病而无法经口摄入。患者被分为4组,根据间歇性或持续性系统与无纤维或富含纤维配方的组合进行喂养。腹泻的5天发生率定义为24小时内出现2次稀便或3次或更多次半固体或液体排便。其他结局变量包括死亡率、住院天数、延长住院时间(超过20天)、发热以及艰难梭菌细胞毒素A/B检测呈阳性的粪便。
与持续/纤维组相比,持续/无纤维组、间歇/纤维组和间歇/无纤维组的相对风险增加分别为2.8[95%置信区间(CI)=1.0 - 8.1]、2.5(95%CI = 0.9 - 7.1)和5.0(95%CI = 1.9 - 13.2)。这些发现与年龄(>80岁)、女性、因呼吸道或泌尿系统感染接受抗生素治疗、接受呼吸支持或意识清醒无关。其他结局无显著差异。
我们得出结论,在因急性病而无法经口摄入的营养良好的老年住院患者中,持续且封闭的肠内喂养并添加纤维可有效降低腹泻发生率。