Tubeless percutaneous neprolithotomy: the new gold standard.

PURPOSE

We present our experience with tubeless percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between July 2004 and December 2006, 121 patients (82 males and 39 females) with 18-70 mm (mean 31.19 mm) renal stones underwent tubeless PCNL leaving only a 6 Fr externalized ureteric catheter. Their ages ranged between 4 and 80 years (mean 37.27). Two patients had bilateral disease, so a total of 123 renal units are included. The procedure was performed under general anesthesia in the prone (110 units) or supine position (13 units). A total of 133 punctures were performed. The punctures were single (114 units), double (8 units), or triple (1 unit). The approach was subcostal through the lower calyx (n=110) or middle calyx (n=10), or supracostal through the middle calyx (n=8) or upper calyx (n=5).

RESULTS

Mean operative time was 46.30 min (range 15-100). Mean reduction in hemoglobin level was 1.57 g (range 0.3-4) with blood transfusion rate 4.13%. Complication rate was 9.9% in the form of perirenal collection (five patients), urinary leakage (two patients), fever (four patients), and hydrothorax (one patient). The ureteric catheter was left for 7-72 h (mean 45.67). Postoperative analgesia was required in 22 patients (18.2%) with mean 22.9 mg diclofenac sodium per patient. Mean hospital stay was 50.69 h (range 12-96) with 106 units (86.18%) rendered stone free, 13 (10.57%) with insignificant residuals, and four units (3.25%) were left with significant residual stones.

CONCLUSIONS

Tubeless PCNL is a good option in non-complicated PCNL with the advantages of reduced hospital stay, low postoperative pain, and little need for postoperative analgesia.