Wollina Uwe, Hansel Gesina, Koch André, Schönlebe Jaqueline, Köstler Erich, Haroske Gunter
Departments of Dermatology and Allergology, Academic Teaching Hospital Dresden-Friedrichstadt, Dresden, Germany.
Am J Clin Dermatol. 2008;9(1):1-14. doi: 10.2165/00128071-200809010-00001.
Tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNFalpha) inhibition is effective in the treatment of moderate-to-severe psoriasis. We report on 120 patients from the literature including six new patients (three women and three men) who developed pustular lesions during treatment with TNFalpha inhibitors. We identified 72 women and 36 men (several papers did not specify the gender of patients) with an age range of 13-78 years (mean 42.3 years). The primary diagnoses were rheumatoid arthritis (n = 61), ankylosing spondylitis (n = 21), psoriasis (n = 10), Crohn disease (n = 8), SAPHO (synovitis acne pustulosis hyperostosis osteitis) syndrome (n = 3), psoriatic arthritis (n = 2), and other diagnoses (n = 15). Psoriasis (except palmoplantar pustular type) was the most common adverse effect during anti-TNFalpha treatment (n = 73), followed by palmoplantar pustular psoriasis (n = 37) and psoriasis of the nail (n = 6), sometimes combined in the same patient. Palmoplantar pustulosis and psoriasiform exanthema was the diagnosis in ten patients each. A positive personal history of psoriasis was recorded in 25 patients. A positive family history was noted in eight patients. No data about personal (n = 7) or family history (n = 46) were available in a number of patients. Newly induced psoriasis was diagnosed in 74 patients whereas an exacerbation or aggravation of a pre-existing psoriasis was noted in another 25 patients. All three TNFalpha inhibitors available on the market were involved: infliximab (63 patients), etanercept (37 patients), and adalimumab (26 patients). Several patients were treated with more than a single TFNalpha inhibitor. The timing of cutaneous adverse effects (psoriasis and psoriasiform rash) varied considerably among patients, ranging from after a single application to a delayed response of up to 63 months after initiation of treatment. The mean time to appearance of the cutaneous adverse effect for all TNFalpha inhibitors was 9.5 months. Cessation of the responsible TNFalpha inhibitor was carried out in 47 patients either alone or in association with adjuvant anti-psoriatic therapy (mostly topical). This resulted in complete remission in 21 patients, partial remission in 20 patients, and stable disease in another three patients; in the other three patients, the outcome was not reported. TNFalpha inhibition was continued in 47 patients but anti-psoriatic adjuvant therapy was introduced. The outcome in this group was complete remission in 22 patients, partial remission in 25 patients, and stable disease in 2 patients. The response rate (complete remission plus partial remission) was 93.2% and 95.9%, respectively, in each group. In six patients, switching from one TNFalpha inhibitor to another one immediately after cutaneous adverse effects occurred resulted in an improvement in five patients. In nine patients, a second TNFalpha inhibitor was initiated after a break in TNFalpha inhibition. The response to a second or third drug in these patients was mixed. The underlying pathomechanisms of induction of psoriasis or psoriasiform exanthemata by TNFalpha inhibitors remain elusive but there is reason to assume that induction of such adverse events has more than one pathophysiology.
肿瘤坏死因子-α(TNFα)抑制疗法在中重度银屑病的治疗中有效。我们从文献中报告了120例患者,包括6例新患者(3名女性和3名男性),他们在接受TNFα抑制剂治疗期间出现了脓疱性皮损。我们确定了72名女性和36名男性(几篇论文未明确患者性别),年龄范围为13 - 78岁(平均42.3岁)。主要诊断包括类风湿性关节炎(n = 61)、强直性脊柱炎(n = 21)、银屑病(n = 10)、克罗恩病(n = 8)、滑膜炎痤疮脓疱病骨肥厚骨炎(SAPHO)综合征(n = 3)、银屑病关节炎(n = 2)以及其他诊断(n = 15)。银屑病(掌跖脓疱型除外)是抗TNFα治疗期间最常见的不良反应(n = 73),其次是掌跖脓疱型银屑病(n = 37)和甲银屑病(n = 6),有时在同一患者中合并出现。掌跖脓疱病和银屑病样疹在各10例患者中被诊断。25例患者有银屑病个人史阳性记录。8例患者有家族史阳性记录。许多患者没有个人(n = 7)或家族史(n = 46)的数据。74例患者被诊断为新诱发的银屑病,另外25例患者出现了原有银屑病的加重或恶化。市场上现有的三种TNFα抑制剂均有涉及:英夫利昔单抗(63例患者)、依那西普(37例患者)和阿达木单抗(26例患者)。几名患者接受了不止一种TNFα抑制剂治疗。皮肤不良反应(银屑病和银屑病样皮疹)出现的时间在患者中差异很大,从单次用药后到治疗开始后长达63个月的延迟反应都有。所有TNFα抑制剂出现皮肤不良反应的平均时间为9.个月。对47例患者单独或联合辅助性抗银屑病治疗(主要是外用)停用了相关的TNFα抑制剂。这导致21例患者完全缓解,20例患者部分缓解,另外3例患者病情稳定;另外3例患者的结果未报告。47例患者继续使用TNFα抑制疗法,但引入了抗银屑病辅助治疗。该组的结果是22例患者完全缓解,25例患者部分缓解,2例患者病情稳定。每组的缓解率(完全缓解加部分缓解)分别为93.2%和95.9%。6例患者在皮肤不良反应出现后立即从一种TNFα抑制剂换用另一种,5例患者病情改善。9例患者在TNFα抑制中断后开始使用第二种TNFα抑制剂。这些患者对第二种或第三种药物的反应不一。TNFα抑制剂诱发银屑病或银屑病样疹的潜在病理机制仍不清楚,但有理由认为此类不良事件的诱发有不止一种病理生理学机制。