Sourbron Steven P, Michaely Henrik J, Reiser Maximilian F, Schoenberg Stefan O
Institute of Clinical Radiology, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Munich, Germany.
Invest Radiol. 2008 Jan;43(1):40-8. doi: 10.1097/RLI.0b013e31815597c5.
Recent animal studies with dynamic contrast enhanced magnetic resonance imaging have demonstrated that a separable compartment model provides more accurate assessments of glomerular filtration than the Patlak model. In this study, the feasibility of the separable compartment model for the measurement of perfusion and filtration in healthy humans is investigated.
Dynamic contrast enhanced magnetic resonance imaging was performed in 15 healthy volunteers. Contrast enhancement curves were analyzed with the separable compartment model on whole kidney regions, cortex regions, and the pixel level. The region of interest values for the kinetic parameters were compared with those obtained from the Patlak model and from a model-free deconvolution analysis.
The separable compartment model provides a good fit to the data over the entire dynamic range. All values of filtration (30 +/- 7.2 and 20 +/- 11 mL/100 mL/Min for kidney and cortex, respectively) are significantly higher than those of the Patlak model (24 +/- 6.4 and 15 +/- 11 mL/100 mL/Min). Values produced by the Patlak model have a higher variability. Whole kidney values of perfusion (229 +/- 57 mL/100 mL/Min) are significantly higher than those of a deconvolution analysis (210 +/- 50 mL/100 mL/Min).
The separable compartment model is feasible for application in humans and sufficiently robust for a pixel analysis. Increased filtration values compared with the Patlak model suggest that the difference in accuracy observed in animal studies is relevant in humans. Increased perfusion values suggest that the separable compartment model corrects for known underestimations in the deconvolution analysis.
近期利用动态对比增强磁共振成像的动物研究表明,与Patlak模型相比,可分离房室模型能更准确地评估肾小球滤过。本研究探讨了可分离房室模型在健康人体中测量灌注和滤过的可行性。
对15名健康志愿者进行动态对比增强磁共振成像。使用可分离房室模型在全肾区域、皮质区域和像素水平分析对比增强曲线。将动力学参数的感兴趣区域值与从Patlak模型和无模型去卷积分析获得的值进行比较。
可分离房室模型在整个动态范围内都能很好地拟合数据。所有滤过值(肾和皮质分别为30±7.2和20±11 mL/100 mL/分钟)均显著高于Patlak模型(24±6.4和15±11 mL/100 mL/分钟)。Patlak模型产生的值变异性更高。全肾灌注值(229±57 mL/100 mL/分钟)显著高于去卷积分析的值(210±50 mL/100 mL/分钟)。
可分离房室模型在人体应用中是可行的,并且对于像素分析具有足够的稳健性。与Patlak模型相比,滤过值增加表明在动物研究中观察到的准确性差异在人体中也相关。灌注值增加表明可分离房室模型纠正了去卷积分析中已知的低估。