Benson A C, Torode M E, Fiatarone Singh M A
School of Medical Sciences, Discipline of Exercise Science, RMIT University, Melbourne, Vic. 3083, Australia.
Obes Rev. 2008 Jan;9(1):43-66. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-789X.2007.00388.x.
The majority of resistance training (RT) research with children to date has focused on pre-adolescents and the safety and efficacy of this type of training rather than the potential metabolic health benefits. Our objectives, using computerized databases, were (i) to systematically review studies utilizing RT interventions with children and adolescents <18 years; (ii) to investigate the metabolic health outcomes (adiposity, lipids, insulin, glucose) associated with RT; (iii) to provide recommendations for future investigations. A total of 12 studies met the review criteria. There is only a small amount of evidence that children and adolescents may derive metabolic health-related adaptations from supervised RT. However, methodological limitations within the body of this literature make it difficult to determine the optimal RT prescription for metabolic fitness in children and adolescents, and the extent and duration of such benefits. More robustly designed single modality randomized controlled trials utilizing standardized reporting and precise outcome assessments are required to determine the extent of health outcomes attributable solely to RT and to enable the development of evidence-based obesity prevention and treatment strategies in this cohort.
迄今为止,大多数针对儿童的抗阻训练(RT)研究都集中在青春期前儿童以及此类训练的安全性和有效性上,而非其对代谢健康的潜在益处。我们利用计算机数据库的目的是:(i)系统回顾针对18岁以下儿童和青少年进行RT干预的研究;(ii)调查与RT相关的代谢健康结果(肥胖、血脂、胰岛素、血糖);(iii)为未来的研究提供建议。共有12项研究符合综述标准。仅有少量证据表明儿童和青少年可能从有监督的RT中获得与代谢健康相关的适应性变化。然而,该文献中的方法学局限性使得难以确定儿童和青少年代谢健康的最佳RT方案,以及此类益处的程度和持续时间。需要设计更严谨的单模式随机对照试验,采用标准化报告和精确的结果评估,以确定仅归因于RT的健康结果程度,并为该人群制定基于证据的肥胖预防和治疗策略。