Yoo Eun Hyung, Cho Hyun Jung, Ki Chang Seok, Lee Soo Youn
Department of Laboratory Medicine, Sungkyunkwan University College of Medicine, Samsung Medical Center, Seoul, Korea.
Korean J Lab Med. 2006 Feb;26(1):1-8. doi: 10.3343/kjlm.2006.26.1.1.
Glucometer is a most widely-used point-of-care testing (POCT) analyzer and plays an important role in diabetes management. We evaluated the performance of the recently developed glucometer, COSMOsensor (Cosmogenome Inc., Seoul, Korea), comparing it with three foreign-made glucometers.
COSMOsensor was evaluated for linearity, precision, comparison of method and analysing time as well as the effect of operator. Other glucometers, Accu-Chek inform (Roche Diagnostics LTD., Mannheim, Germany), Precision(TM)PCx (Abbott Laboratories, Bedford, MA, USA), and SureStep(R)Flexx (LifeScan Inc., Milpitas, CA, USA) were evaluated for the same categories according to NCCLS guidelines.
All four glucometers showed a good linearity (r>/=0.9814) and the within-run and total-run coefficients of variation (CVs) were within 3.5%. A high correlation (r>/=0.9659) was also found between the glucometers and Hitachi 7600 (Hitachi Co., Tokyo, Japan) in the central laboratory. Although differences with the reference method were within an allowable range, all glucometers showed variable bias compared with the reference method.
The COSMOsensor showed a good analytical performance in linearity, precision, and correlation with the reference method, when compared with other foreign-made glucometers. Its rapid turnaround time and easy operation are appropriate for diabetes management and a rapid POCT analyzer. All glucometers showed variable biases, which might be due to different calibration status.
血糖仪是使用最为广泛的即时检验(POCT)分析仪,在糖尿病管理中发挥着重要作用。我们评估了最近研发的血糖仪COSMOsensor(韩国首尔的Cosmogenome公司)的性能,并将其与三款国外生产的血糖仪进行比较。
对COSMOsensor进行线性、精密度、方法比较、分析时间以及操作人员影响等方面的评估。根据美国国家临床实验室标准委员会(NCCLS)的指南,对其他血糖仪,即拜安易血糖仪(德国曼海姆的罗氏诊断有限公司)、Precision(TM)PCx血糖仪(美国马萨诸塞州贝德福德的雅培实验室)和稳豪倍优血糖仪(美国加利福尼亚州米尔皮塔斯的强生公司生命科学部)进行相同项目的评估。
所有四款血糖仪均显示出良好的线性(r≥0.9814),批内和总批变异系数(CVs)均在3.5%以内。在中心实验室中,这些血糖仪与日立7600(日本东京的日立公司)之间也发现了高度相关性(r≥0.9659)。尽管与参考方法的差异在允许范围内,但与参考方法相比,所有血糖仪均显示出不同程度的偏差。
与其他国外生产的血糖仪相比,COSMOsensor在线性、精密度以及与参考方法的相关性方面表现出良好的分析性能。其快速的周转时间和简便的操作适合糖尿病管理及快速POCT分析仪。所有血糖仪均显示出不同程度的偏差,这可能是由于校准状态不同所致。