Critchfield Kenneth L, Levy Kenneth N, Clarkin John F, Kernberg Otto F
IRT Clinic, University of Utah Neuropsychiatric Institute, Salt lake City, UT 84108, USA.
J Clin Psychol. 2008 Jan;64(1):67-82. doi: 10.1002/jclp.20434.
Attachment theory provides a framework for understanding and predicting critical aspects of aggression in the personality disorders. An association between borderline personality disorder (BPD) and insecure forms of adult attachment marked by high relationship anxiety has been repeatedly observed in the empirical literature. Aggression also has been linked to insecure attachment. The present study extends previous work by exploring the degree to which the underlying attachment dimensions of relationship anxiety and avoidance are associated in BPD with the following forms of hostility: (a) direct aggression (verbal or physical) initiated towards others, (b) expectation/perception of aggression from others (including "reactive" counteraggression when/if provoked), (c) aggression directed towards the self in the form of suicidality or parasuicidality, and (d) affective experience of irritability or anger. The issue was studied in a sample of 92 patients diagnosed with BPD. Results show significant association between more fearful forms of attachment (simultaneous presence of relationship anxiety and avoidance) and the more reactive form of aggression involving expectation of hostility from others. Self-harm was significantly associated only with relational avoidance while anger and irritability were associated only with relational anxiety. Implications for understanding relational aspects of BPD aggression in research and clinical work are discussed.
依恋理论为理解和预测人格障碍中攻击行为的关键方面提供了一个框架。实证文献中反复观察到边缘型人格障碍(BPD)与以高度关系焦虑为特征的不安全成人依恋形式之间存在关联。攻击行为也与不安全依恋有关。本研究通过探讨关系焦虑和回避这两种潜在依恋维度在BPD中与以下几种敌意形式的关联程度,扩展了先前的研究:(a)对他人发起的直接攻击(言语或身体上的),(b)对他人攻击的预期/感知(包括在被激怒时的“反应性”反击),(c)以自杀或准自杀形式指向自身的攻击,以及(d)易怒或愤怒的情感体验。该问题在92名被诊断为BPD的患者样本中进行了研究。结果表明,更恐惧的依恋形式(关系焦虑和回避同时存在)与涉及对他人敌意预期的更具反应性的攻击形式之间存在显著关联。自我伤害仅与关系回避显著相关,而愤怒和易怒仅与关系焦虑相关。文中讨论了在研究和临床工作中理解BPD攻击行为的关系方面的意义。