Turner S, Sweeney M, Kennedy C, Macpherson L
Dental Health Services Research Unit, University of Dundee, MacKenzie Building, Dundee, UK.
J Intellect Disabil Res. 2008 Jan;52(Pt 1):29-36. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2788.2007.00971.x.
Research on the dental health of people with intellectual disability has consistently reported more untreated dental disease, more extractions and fewer fillings than in the general population. This paper describes the oral health of participants at the 2005 Glasgow Special Olympics (SO), relating this to the general population studied in the 1998 UK Adult Dental Health Survey (ADHS) and to participants' age and region of residence.
Consenting SO participants were offered oral examinations which followed the standardized SO protocol plus an innovative soft tissue examination. Urgency of any treatment required was noted and reported to participants and carers. Three measures of good dental health--having 21 or more natural teeth, absence of fillings and having no obvious untreated decay--were compared across age groups, regions and with the general population. Logistic regression was used to control for age differences between regions.
In total, 1021 oral examinations were completed. Older SO participants were more likely to have fewer than 21 teeth and to have fillings, untreated decay, gum inflammation and heavy plaque levels. In all, 28% of SO participants had 21 or more teeth, no fillings and no obvious decay. Those from the north, midlands and south regions of England had significantly more chance of good dental health so defined compared with participants from Scotland [ORs 1.67 (1.09, 2.67), 1.69 (1.12, 2.54), 1.99 (1.26, 3.16), respectively]. Compared with the general population surveyed in the 1998 ADHS study, SO participants were more likely to be free from fillings and obvious untreated decay, but fewer had 21 or more natural teeth among older age groups. Nine per cent were found to have soft tissue problems, and one in four of these required follow-up. Gum inflammation was common. Overall, 5% of participants were judged to require urgent treatment for dental or soft tissue problems and 40% to require non-urgent treatment. This rose to 9% and 66% respectively among those aged 35 years and over.
The low prevalence of untreated decay and fillings among SO participants compared with the general population may be due to their being well supported by family and carers. The study identifies the vulnerability of the older participants to dental problems, and this may indicate greater difficulty maintaining surveillance as individuals age or informal carers become less able or available. Regional variations are similar to those found in the general population. The implications for the organization of care for this group are discussed.
关于智障人士口腔健康的研究一直表明,与普通人群相比,他们有更多未经治疗的牙病、更多的拔牙情况以及更少的补牙情况。本文描述了2005年格拉斯哥特殊奥林匹克运动会(SO)参与者的口腔健康状况,并将其与1998年英国成人牙科健康调查(ADHS)中所研究的普通人群以及参与者的年龄和居住地区进行关联。
同意参与的SO参与者接受了口腔检查,检查遵循标准化的SO方案并增加了一项创新性的软组织检查。记录了所需任何治疗的紧迫性,并告知参与者及其护理人员。比较了不同年龄组、不同地区以及与普通人群在三项良好口腔健康指标上的情况,这三项指标分别为拥有21颗或更多天然牙、无补牙以及无明显未经治疗的龋齿。使用逻辑回归来控制地区间的年龄差异。
总共完成了1021次口腔检查。年龄较大的SO参与者更有可能牙齿少于21颗,并有补牙、未经治疗的龋齿、牙龈炎症和牙菌斑大量堆积的情况。总体而言,28%的SO参与者拥有21颗或更多牙齿、无补牙且无明显龋齿。与来自苏格兰的参与者相比,来自英格兰北部、中部和南部地区的参与者被定义为拥有良好口腔健康的可能性显著更高[比值比分别为1.67(1.09,2.67)、1.69(1.12,2.54)、1.99(1.26,3.16)]。与1998年ADHS研究中调查的普通人群相比,SO参与者更有可能没有补牙和明显未经治疗的龋齿,但在年龄较大的组中拥有21颗或更多天然牙的人较少。发现9%的人存在软组织问题,其中四分之一需要后续跟进。牙龈炎症很常见。总体而言,5%的参与者被判定需要对牙齿或软组织问题进行紧急治疗,40%的人需要非紧急治疗。在35岁及以上的人群中,这一比例分别升至9%和66%。
与普通人群相比,SO参与者中未经治疗的龋齿和补牙情况的低患病率可能是由于他们得到了家人和护理人员的良好支持。该研究确定了年龄较大的参与者在牙齿问题上的脆弱性,这可能表明随着个人年龄增长或非正式护理人员能力下降或无法提供护理,维持监测会更加困难。地区差异与在普通人群中发现的情况相似。讨论了对该群体护理组织的影响。