Teerawichitchainan Bussarawan, Phillips James F
Population Council, Hanoi, Vietnam.
Soc Sci Med. 2008 Mar;66(5):1118-30. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2007.10.020. Epub 2008 Jan 7.
Vietnam's sustained investment in primary healthcare since the onset of socialism has lowered infant and childhood mortality rates and improved life expectancy, exceeding progress achieved in other poor countries with comparable levels of income per capita. The recent introduction of user fees for primary healthcare services has generated concern that economic policies may have adversely affected health-seeking behavior and health outcomes of the poor, particularly among impoverished families who are members of socially marginalized minority groups. This paper examines this debate by analyzing parental recall of illness and care-seeking for sick children under the age of 5 years recorded by the 2001-2002 Vietnam National Health Survey. We estimate statistical models of the determinants of parental recall of incidence and response to illness among their children. Ethnic minority parents less frequently reported their children to have been sick than Kinh and Chinese parents. When they recognize an illness episode, minority parents are less likely to seek care -- whether professional consultation or self-prescribed care -- than non-minority parents. Ethnic differentials are evident in all geographic and income levels, although adverse effects of minority status are most pronounced among poor households in remote areas. Regression estimates of the effects of ethnicity and maternal education on health decisions are pronounced even when poverty effects are controlled, suggesting that social equity may have been under-emphasized in Vietnam's early health policy deliberations. Policies extending free healthcare to poor communes affect parental decisions to seek professional care or self-prescribed care among better-off parents without affecting parental decision making among the poor. Early health initiatives for the poor may therefore have failed to offset equity problems confronting impoverished ethnic minority families.
自社会主义制度建立以来,越南对初级医疗保健持续投入,降低了婴儿和儿童死亡率,提高了预期寿命,所取得的进展超过了其他人均收入水平相当的贫困国家。最近,初级医疗保健服务开始收取用户费用,这引发了人们的担忧,即经济政策可能对穷人,尤其是社会边缘化少数群体中的贫困家庭的就医行为和健康状况产生了不利影响。本文通过分析2001 - 2002年越南全国健康调查记录的5岁以下患病儿童的家长对疾病的回忆以及就医情况,对这一争论进行了研究。我们估计了家长回忆孩子发病情况及其对疾病反应的决定因素的统计模型。少数民族家长报告孩子生病的频率低于京族和华族家长。当他们意识到孩子生病时,少数民族家长比非少数民族家长更不太可能寻求治疗——无论是专业咨询还是自行用药治疗。尽管在偏远地区的贫困家庭中,少数民族身份的不利影响最为明显,但在所有地理区域和收入水平上,族裔差异都很明显。即使控制了贫困因素,族裔和母亲教育程度对健康决策影响的回归估计仍然显著,这表明越南早期的卫生政策审议可能没有充分强调社会公平。将免费医疗保健扩展到贫困公社的政策影响了富裕家庭家长寻求专业治疗或自行用药治疗的决定,但对贫困家庭家长的决策没有影响。因此,早期针对穷人的卫生举措可能未能抵消贫困少数民族家庭面临的公平问题。