Fattore Giovanni, Torbica Aleksandra
CERGAS and Institute of Public Administration and Health Care, Bocconi University, Milan, Italy.
Health Econ. 2008 Jan;17(1 Suppl):S71-82. doi: 10.1002/hec.1324.
The number of cataract extractions has increased substantially over time. At present, cataract surgery is estimated to be the most common single procedure performed in the developed world. The present study compares the costs of a cataract intervention across nine European countries. To enhance comparability, data were collected using a common template based on a case vignette. Adequate data for analysis were collected from 41 providers and were used to evaluate variation across countries and providers. Ordinary least squares and a multilevel model were used to investigate cost variation. Mean total costs per cataract intervention varied considerably from country to country, ranging from 318 euros in Hungary to 1087 euros in Italy. Variations of a similar magnitude were detected for personnel costs and overheads. However, variations in the cost of the lens were more modest. Overall, our results confirm expectations about the causes of cost variations across EU member states, indicating that these variations may be attributable to the quantity of resources used in performing the operation, the price of resources, and the type of setting in which the operation is performed. The study highlights how accounting practices and available cost data differ across Europe. It also shows the feasibility of collecting data on the basis of vignettes using common cost templates. Studies following this approach will gain importance if cross-country comparisons are to be used to promote European benchmarking exercises.
随着时间的推移,白内障摘除手术的数量大幅增加。目前,白内障手术估计是发达国家最常见的单一手术。本研究比较了九个欧洲国家白内障干预措施的成本。为提高可比性,使用基于病例 vignette 的通用模板收集数据。从 41 个提供者处收集了足够的分析数据,并用于评估各国和各提供者之间的差异。使用普通最小二乘法和多层次模型来研究成本差异。每次白内障干预的平均总成本在不同国家之间差异很大,从匈牙利的 318 欧元到意大利的 1087 欧元不等。在人员成本和间接费用方面也发现了类似程度的差异。然而,晶状体成本的差异较小。总体而言,我们的结果证实了对欧盟成员国成本差异原因的预期,表明这些差异可能归因于手术中使用的资源数量、资源价格以及进行手术的环境类型。该研究突出了欧洲各地会计实践和可用成本数据的差异。它还展示了使用通用成本模板根据 vignette 收集数据的可行性。如果要利用跨国比较来推动欧洲的基准测试活动,采用这种方法的研究将变得更加重要。