Cohen Marta C, Paley Martyn N, Griffiths Paul D, Whitby Elspeth H
Department of Histopathology, Sheffield Children's NHS Foundation Trust, Western Bank, Sheffield S10 2TH, United Kingdom.
Pediatr Dev Pathol. 2008 Jan-Feb;11(1):1-9. doi: 10.2350/07-01-0213.1.
The decline in the postmortem (PM) autopsy rate in the United Kingdom paralleled the change in public perception of this procedure after the organ retention crisis in 2000. The introduction of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the fetal, perinatal, and pediatric autopsy led some investigators to propose that MRI could replace the conventional PM. We assessed the role of MRI in fetal autopsy as an addition or a potential replacement method to the conventional PM and to evaluate the benefits and limitations of each technique. We retrospectively reviewed the PM and MRI examination of 100 fetuses. The MRI was limited to the brain or brain and spinal cord. Forty-six cases involved termination of pregnancy; 30 were intrauterine fetal deaths/stillbirths; 16 were premature deliveries followed by neonatal death; and 8 were miscarriages. The mean gestational age of all cases was 25.54 weeks (range: 13-41 weeks). In 54 of the 90 full PMs, there was a complete agreement between the MRI and autopsy findings on the morphology of the brain and spine. Despite this agreement, the information gained at the PM was relevant to find the cause or mechanism of death in 20 of 54 cases (37%). In 24 autopsies the MRI added valuable information to the autopsy. However, if MRI had been the only investigation, essential information would have been lost in 17 of 24 cases (71%). In 12 cases the PM was clearly superior to the MRI. The integrated result obtained from the traditional autopsy remains crucial in determining the cause or mechanism of the malformation or of the fetal/perinatal death and accordingly is important for the counseling offered to parents regarding the recurrence risk for future pregnancies.
英国尸检率的下降与2000年器官保留危机后公众对该程序看法的变化同步。胎儿、围产期和儿科尸检中磁共振成像(MRI)的引入使一些研究者提出MRI可取代传统尸检。我们评估了MRI在胎儿尸检中作为传统尸检的补充或潜在替代方法的作用,并评估了每种技术的益处和局限性。我们回顾性分析了100例胎儿的尸检和MRI检查情况。MRI检查仅限于脑部或脑部及脊髓。46例为终止妊娠;30例为宫内胎儿死亡/死产;16例为早产后继发新生儿死亡;8例为流产。所有病例的平均孕周为25.54周(范围:13 - 41周)。在90例完整尸检中的54例中,MRI与尸检在脑和脊柱形态学方面的发现完全一致。尽管有这种一致性,但在54例中的20例(37%)尸检中获得的信息与找出死亡原因或机制相关。在24例尸检中,MRI为尸检增添了有价值的信息。然而,如果仅进行MRI检查,在24例中的17例(71%)中会丢失重要信息。在12例中,尸检明显优于MRI。从传统尸检获得的综合结果对于确定畸形或胎儿/围产期死亡的原因或机制仍然至关重要,因此对于向父母提供关于未来妊娠复发风险的咨询很重要。