Savage Ceri, Lieven Elena, Theakston Anna, Tomasello Michael
Department of Psychology, Manchester University, UK.
Dev Sci. 2003 Nov 1;6(5):557-567. doi: 10.1111/1467-7687.00312.
The current studies used a priming methodology to assess the abstractness of children's early syntactic constructions. In the main study, 3-, 4- and 6-year-old children were asked to describe a prime picture by repeating either an active or a passive sentence, and then they were left to their own devices to describe a target picture. For half the children at each age, the prime sentences they repeated had high lexical overlap with the sentence they were likely to produce for the target, whereas for the other half there was very low lexical overlap between prime and target. The main result was that 6-year-old children showed both lexical and structural priming for both the active transitive and passive constructions, whereas 3- and 4-year-old children showed lexical priming only. This pattern of results would seem to indicate that 6-year-old children have relatively abstract representations of these constructions, whereas 3- and 4-year-old children have as an integral part of their representations certain specific lexical items, especially pronouns and some grammatical morphemes. In a second study it was found that children did not need to repeat the prime out loud in order to be primed - suggesting that the priming effect observed concerns not just peripheral production mechanisms but underlying linguistic representations common to comprehension and production. These results support the view that young children develop abstract linguistic representations gradually during the preschool years.
当前的研究采用启动法来评估儿童早期句法结构的抽象程度。在主要研究中,要求3岁、4岁和6岁的儿童通过重复主动句或被动句来描述启动图片,然后让他们自主描述目标图片。在每个年龄段的儿童中,一半儿童重复的启动句与他们可能为目标图片生成的句子有高度的词汇重叠,而另一半儿童的启动句与目标句之间的词汇重叠非常低。主要结果是,6岁儿童在主动及物结构和被动结构上都表现出词汇和结构启动效应,而3岁和4岁儿童仅表现出词汇启动效应。这种结果模式似乎表明,6岁儿童对这些结构有相对抽象的表征,而3岁和4岁儿童在其表征中作为一个不可或缺的部分包含某些特定的词汇项,尤其是代词和一些语法语素。在第二项研究中发现,儿童无需大声重复启动句就能受到启动——这表明观察到的启动效应不仅涉及外围的生成机制,还涉及理解和生成所共有的潜在语言表征。这些结果支持了这样一种观点,即幼儿在学前阶段逐渐发展出抽象的语言表征。