Otto Karl
Vancouver Cancer Centre, BC Cancer Agency, Vancouver, British Columbia V5Z 4E6, Canada.
Med Phys. 2008 Jan;35(1):310-7. doi: 10.1118/1.2818738.
In this work a novel plan optimization platform is presented where treatment is delivered efficiently and accurately in a single dynamically modulated arc. Improvements in patient care achieved through image-guided positioning and plan adaptation have resulted in an increase in overall treatment times. Intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) has also increased treatment time by requiring a larger number of beam directions, increased monitor units (MU), and, in the case of tomotherapy, a slice-by-slice delivery. In order to maintain a similar level of patient throughput it will be necessary to increase the efficiency of treatment delivery. The solution proposed here is a novel aperture-based algorithm for treatment plan optimization where dose is delivered during a single gantry arc of up to 360 deg. The technique is similar to tomotherapy in that a full 360 deg of beam directions are available for optimization but is fundamentally different in that the entire dose volume is delivered in a single source rotation. The new technique is referred to as volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT). Multileaf collimator (MLC) leaf motion and number of MU per degree of gantry rotation is restricted during the optimization so that gantry rotation speed, leaf translation speed, and dose rate maxima do not excessively limit the delivery efficiency. During planning, investigators model continuous gantry motion by a coarse sampling of static gantry positions and fluence maps or MLC aperture shapes. The technique presented here is unique in that gantry and MLC position sampling is progressively increased throughout the optimization. Using the full gantry range will theoretically provide increased flexibility in generating highly conformal treatment plans. In practice, the additional flexibility is somewhat negated by the additional constraints placed on the amount of MLC leaf motion between gantry samples. A series of studies are performed that characterize the relationship between gantry and MLC sampling, dose modeling accuracy, and optimization time. Results show that gantry angle and MLC sample spacing as low as 1 deg and 0.5 cm, respectively, is desirable for accurate dose modeling. It is also shown that reducing the sample spacing dramatically reduces the ability of the optimization to arrive at a solution. The competing benefits of having small and large sample spacing are mutually realized using the progressive sampling technique described here. Preliminary results show that plans generated with VMAT optimization exhibit dose distributions equivalent or superior to static gantry IMRT. Timing studies have shown that the VMAT technique is well suited for on-line verification and adaptation with delivery times that are reduced to approximately 1.5-3 min for a 200 cGy fraction.
在这项工作中,提出了一种新型的计划优化平台,在该平台中,治疗可以在单个动态调制弧中高效且精确地进行。通过图像引导定位和计划调整实现的患者护理改善导致了总体治疗时间的增加。调强放射治疗(IMRT)也因需要更多的射束方向、增加的监测单位(MU)以及在断层放射治疗的情况下逐片递送而增加了治疗时间。为了维持相似的患者吞吐量水平,有必要提高治疗递送的效率。这里提出的解决方案是一种用于治疗计划优化的基于孔径的新型算法,其中剂量在单个高达360度的机架弧期间递送。该技术与断层放射治疗类似,因为有完整的360度射束方向可用于优化,但根本不同之处在于整个剂量体积在单个源旋转中递送。这种新技术被称为容积调强弧形治疗(VMAT)。在优化过程中,多叶准直器(MLC)叶片运动和每度机架旋转的MU数量受到限制,以便机架旋转速度、叶片平移速度和剂量率最大值不会过度限制递送效率。在计划过程中,研究人员通过对静态机架位置和注量图或MLC孔径形状进行粗略采样来模拟连续的机架运动。这里提出的技术的独特之处在于,在整个优化过程中,机架和MLC位置采样会逐渐增加。理论上,使用整个机架范围将在生成高度适形的治疗计划时提供更大的灵活性。在实际中,额外的灵活性在一定程度上被对机架样本之间MLC叶片运动量施加的额外约束所抵消。进行了一系列研究,以表征机架和MLC采样、剂量建模精度和优化时间之间的关系。结果表明,对于精确的剂量建模,机架角度和MLC样本间距分别低至1度和0.5厘米是理想的。还表明,减小样本间距会显著降低优化找到解决方案的能力。使用这里描述的渐进采样技术可以相互实现小样本间距和大样本间距的竞争优势。初步结果表明,通过VMAT优化生成的计划表现出与静态机架IMRT相当或更优的剂量分布。时间研究表明,VMAT技术非常适合在线验证和调整,对于200 cGy的分次,递送时间可减少到约1.5 - 3分钟。