Manninen H, Remes J, Partanen K, Tynkkynen P, Mykkänen L, Laakso M, Soimakallio S, Pyörälä K
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Kuopio University Central Hospital, Finland.
Acta Radiol. 1991 May;32(3):226-31.
Inter- and intraobserver variation and diagnostic accuracy in estimation of heart size and pulmonary vasculature were evaluated for conventional film-screen technique and image intensifier photofluorography. Interpretation of 218 p.a. and lateral chest films by both imaging techniques was performed independently by 4 readers. Heart size relative to body surface area measured from the plain chest films was used as the reference in cardiac size determination. Overall diagnostic accuracies of conventional radiography and image intensifier photofluorography for cardiomegaly were close to each other, 0.70 vs 0.68, respectively. Specificity of film-screen radiography was better than that of photofluorography (0.92 vs 0.84, p less than 0.05). Interobserver agreement was poor both in assessment of the heart size and pulmonary vasculature (range of kappa coefficients 0.18-0.59) while the intraobserver consistency (kappa coefficients 0.60-0.85) was good to excellent. The results suggest a limited usefulness of visual assessment of heart size and pulmonary vasculature in chest roentgenographs.
针对传统屏-片技术和影像增强器荧光摄影术,评估了观察者间和观察者内的变异性以及心脏大小和肺血管系统估计的诊断准确性。4位阅片者分别独立地用这两种成像技术解读了218张后前位和侧位胸片。从胸部平片测量的心脏大小相对于体表面积被用作心脏大小测定的参考。传统放射摄影和影像增强器荧光摄影对心脏扩大的总体诊断准确性彼此接近,分别为0.70和0.68。屏-片放射摄影的特异性优于荧光摄影(0.92对0.84,p<0.05)。在心脏大小和肺血管系统评估中,观察者间一致性较差(kappa系数范围为0.18 - 0.59),而观察者内一致性(kappa系数0.60 - 0.85)良好至优秀。结果表明,胸部X线片中对心脏大小和肺血管系统的视觉评估作用有限。