Tubman T R, Shields M D, Craig B G, Mulholland H C, Nevin N C
Cardiac Unit, Royal Belfast Hospital for Sick Children.
BMJ. 1991 Jun 15;302(6790):1425-7. doi: 10.1136/bmj.302.6790.1425.
To determine the effectiveness of clinical examination, chest radiography, and electrocardiography compared with echocardiography in detecting congenital heart disease early in the life of children with Down's syndrome.
Prospective two year screening survey.
Regional paediatric cardiology service, Northern Ireland.
81 newborn infants with Down's syndrome born in Northern Ireland between November 1987 and November 1989.
Clinical examination, chest radiography, and electrocardiography soon after birth followed by cross sectional Doppler echocardiography.
Diagnostic ability of clinical examination, radiography, and electrocardiography compared with echocardiographic findings.
34 babies had congenital heart disease detected by echocardiography (13 had atrioventricular septal defects, seven secundum atrial septal defects, six a solitary patent ductus arteriosus, five isolated ventricular septal defects, and three combinations of heart defects). Individual examination methods were insensitive (the sensitivity of clinical examination was 0.53, of radiography 0.44, and of electrocardiography 0.41) but highly specific (the specificity of clinical examination was 0.94, of radiography 0.98, and of electrocardiography 1.0), although sensitivity improved when the three techniques were combined (the sensitivity was 0.71, the specificity 0.91).
Echocardiography performed early in life can detect congenital heart disease that might otherwise be missed. Early detection may help prevent complications such as pulmonary vascular disease that may adversely affect the outcome of cardiac surgery.
比较临床检查、胸部X线摄影和心电图检查与超声心动图检查在唐氏综合征患儿生命早期检测先天性心脏病的有效性。
为期两年的前瞻性筛查调查。
北爱尔兰地区儿科心脏病服务机构。
1987年11月至1989年11月在北爱尔兰出生的81名唐氏综合征新生儿。
出生后不久进行临床检查、胸部X线摄影和心电图检查,随后进行横断面多普勒超声心动图检查。
将临床检查、X线摄影和心电图检查的诊断能力与超声心动图检查结果进行比较。
34例婴儿经超声心动图检查发现患有先天性心脏病(13例为房室间隔缺损,7例为继发孔型房间隔缺损,6例为孤立性动脉导管未闭,5例为孤立性室间隔缺损,3例为心脏缺陷组合)。单项检查方法敏感性较低(临床检查的敏感性为0.53,X线摄影为0.44,心电图为0.41),但特异性较高(临床检查的特异性为0.94,X线摄影为0.98,心电图为1.0),不过三种技术联合使用时敏感性有所提高(敏感性为0.71,特异性为0.91)。
生命早期进行超声心动图检查可检测出可能被漏诊的先天性心脏病。早期检测有助于预防可能对心脏手术结果产生不利影响的并发症,如肺血管疾病。