Razak Ishak A, Latifah Raja R J, Jaafar Nasruddin, Abu Hassan M I, Ab Murat Norintan
Faculty of Dentistry, University of Malaya, 50603, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
J Dent Educ. 2008 Mar;72(3):364-9.
A survey was conducted to assess competencies of dental graduates of the Faculty of Dentistry, University of Malaya, as perceived by the graduates and their employers, based on the five-year undergraduate curriculum introduced in 1995. All senior dental officers in the Ministry of Health (MOH), representing employers, and all 164 dental graduates of the years 2000, 2001, and 2002 were sent a self-administered questionnaire covering eight areas of competency. The respondents had to rate these areas on a scale of 1 (very poor) to 4 (very good). The responses for each area were then dichotomized into poor (1 and 2) and good (3 and 4). If less than 60 percent of the respondents rated an area as good, then it was categorized as needing attention; 60-69 percent as satisfactory; and 70 percent and above as excellent. One hundred and six graduates (64.6 percent) and twenty-nine employers (96.7 percent) responded; of the graduates, 73.6 percent were working in the MOH and 22.6 percent in private practice. About 57.1 percent of employers reported that at least five graduates have worked under them. Graduates (85.7 percent) and employers (83.3 percent) agreed that graduates have excellent skills in communication. Although all graduates perceived their competency to be excellent in the four areas (treatment planning; community-based skills; management, administrative skills, and personal management; and professional development skills), employers felt that these are the areas that are of concern and needed attention. In conclusion, whilst generally the graduates' level of competency in almost all areas is acceptable or good, there are areas of concern that need to be addressed to further improve the five-year curriculum at the University of Malaya.
基于1995年引入的五年制本科课程,进行了一项调查,以评估马来亚大学牙科学院牙科毕业生的能力,这些能力由毕业生及其雇主感知。卫生部所有高级牙科官员(代表雇主)以及2000年、2001年和2002年的所有164名牙科毕业生都收到了一份涵盖八个能力领域的自填式问卷。受访者必须按照1(非常差)至4(非常好)的等级对这些领域进行评分。然后将每个领域的回答分为差(1和2)和好(3和4)两类。如果不到60%的受访者将一个领域评为好,那么该领域就被归类为需要关注;60 - 69%为满意;70%及以上为优秀。106名毕业生(64.6%)和29名雇主(96.7%)做出了回应;在毕业生中,73.6%在卫生部工作,22.6%从事私人执业。约57.1%的雇主报告称,至少有五名毕业生曾在他们手下工作。毕业生(85.7%)和雇主(83.3%)一致认为毕业生在沟通方面具备优秀技能。尽管所有毕业生都认为自己在四个领域(治疗计划;基于社区的技能;管理、行政技能和个人管理;以及专业发展技能)的能力优秀,但雇主认为这些是令人担忧且需要关注的领域。总之,虽然总体而言毕业生在几乎所有领域的能力水平是可接受的或良好的,但仍有一些令人担忧的领域需要解决,以进一步改进马来亚大学的五年制课程。