Platzer Patrick, Vécsei Vilmos, Thalhammer Gerhild, Oberleitner Gerhard, Schurz Mark, Gaebler Christian
Department of Traumatology, Medical University of Vienna, Waehringer Guertel, Vienna, Austria.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2008 Mar 15;33(6):624-30. doi: 10.1097/BRS.0b013e318166dfb8.
A retrospective case series.
To determine the clinical and radiographic long-term results after posterior atlanto-axial arthrodesis of odontoid nonunions.
Nonunion of odontoid fractures is a relatively common and dreaded complication after surgical and nonoperative treatment of these injuries. Although there might be a significant rate, which require surgical stabilization due to atlanto-axial instability, only few publications have covered this issue and presented reliable long-term results.
We retrospectively analyzed the clinical and radiographic records of 9 (4 women and 5 men) patients with an average age of 68 (42-78) years at the time of injury who had undergone posterior atlanto-axial arthrodesis for surgical treatment of odontoid nonunions between 1988 and 2004. For posterior atlanto-axial arthrodesis, we performed either C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation, or posterior wiring and bone grafting, or a combination of these 2 techniques.
Eight patients achieved a satisfactory clinical outcome and returned to their preinjury activity level. The Smiley-Webster scale showed an overall functional outcome score of 2.2, which was 0.9 points superior to the outcome score before surgery. Neurologic deficits after operative treatment of the odontoid nonunion were evaluated in 2 patients. In all the other patients with primary neurologic deficits or delayed neurologic sequelae we saw a full recovery. Solid bony fusion of the cervical arthrodesis was achieved in all of the patients. Failures of reduction or fixation were noted in 2 patients, but no reoperations were necessary.
In summary, we had a satisfactory outcome after surgical treatment of odontoid nonunions in patients with atlanto-axial instability and severe motion pain at the cervical spine. With a bony union rate of 100% and a noticeable improvement of clinical results and neurologic function, posterior atlanto-axial arthrodesis seems to be an appropriate option for nonunited odontoid fractures that require surgical stabilization.
回顾性病例系列研究。
确定齿状突不愈合后路寰枢关节融合术后的临床及影像学长期疗效。
齿状突骨折不愈合是这些损伤手术及非手术治疗后相对常见且可怕的并发症。尽管可能有相当比例因寰枢椎不稳需要手术稳定,但仅有少数出版物涉及此问题并给出可靠的长期疗效。
我们回顾性分析了1988年至2004年间因齿状突不愈合接受后路寰枢关节融合术的9例患者(4例女性,5例男性)的临床及影像学记录,受伤时平均年龄68岁(42 - 78岁)。对于后路寰枢关节融合术,我们采用了C1 - C2经关节螺钉固定、后路钢丝固定及植骨或这两种技术联合应用。
8例患者获得满意的临床疗效并恢复至伤前活动水平。Smiley - Webster量表显示总体功能结局评分为2.2分,比术前结局评分高0.9分。2例患者评估了齿状突不愈合手术治疗后的神经功能缺损情况。在所有其他有原发性神经功能缺损或迟发性神经后遗症的患者中,我们观察到完全恢复。所有患者均实现了颈椎融合的坚固骨融合。2例患者出现复位或固定失败,但无需再次手术。
总之,对于伴有寰枢椎不稳及颈椎严重活动痛的齿状突不愈合患者,手术治疗取得了满意的疗效。后路寰枢关节融合术骨融合率达100%,临床疗效及神经功能有显著改善,似乎是需要手术稳定的齿状突骨折不愈合的合适选择。