DeThorne Laura S, Petrill Stephen A, Hart Sara A, Channell Ron W, Campbell Rebecca J, Deater-Deckard Kirby, Thompson Lee Anne, Vandenbergh David J
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 901 South Sixth Street, Champaign, IL 61820, USA.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2008 Apr;51(2):423-35. doi: 10.1044/1092-4388(2008/031).
The present study examined the extent of genetic and environmental influences on individual differences in children's conversational language use.
Behavioral genetic analyses focused on conversational measures and 2 standardized tests from 380 twins (M = 7.13 years) during the 2nd year of the Western Reserve Reading Project (S. A. Petrill, K. Deater-Deckard, L. A. Thompson, L. S. DeThorne, & C. Schatschneider, 2006) Multivariate analyses using latent factors were conducted to examine the extent of genetic overlap and specificity between conversational and formalized language.
Multivariate analyses revealed a heritability of .70 for the conversational language factor and .45 for the formal language factor, with a significant genetic correlation of .37 between the two factors. Specific genetic effects were also significant for the conversational factor.
The current study indicated that over half of the variance in children's conversational language skills can be accounted for by genetic effects with no evidence of significant shared environmental influence. This finding casts an alternative lens on past studies that have attributed differences in children's spontaneous language use to differences in environmental language exposure. In addition, multivariate results generally support the context-dependent construction of language knowledge, as suggested by the theory of activity and situated cognition (J. S. Brown, A. Collins, & P. Duguid, 1989; T. A. Ukrainetz, 1998), but also indicate some degree of overlap between language use in conversational and formalized assessment contexts.
本研究考察了遗传和环境因素对儿童对话语言使用个体差异的影响程度。
行为遗传学分析聚焦于对话测量以及来自380对双胞胎(平均年龄7.13岁)在西部储备阅读项目第二年的两项标准化测试(S.A. 佩特里尔、K. 迪特尔 - 德卡德、L.A. 汤普森、L.S. 德索恩和C. 沙茨施耐德,2006)。使用潜在因素进行多变量分析,以考察对话语言和形式化语言之间的遗传重叠程度和特异性。
多变量分析显示,对话语言因素的遗传率为0.70,形式化语言因素的遗传率为0.45,两个因素之间的遗传相关性显著,为0.37。对话因素的特定遗传效应也很显著。
当前研究表明,儿童对话语言技能中超过一半的变异可由遗传效应解释,且没有证据表明存在显著的共享环境影响。这一发现为过去将儿童自发语言使用差异归因于环境语言接触差异的研究提供了另一种视角。此外,多变量结果总体上支持了活动和情境认知理论(J.S. 布朗、A. 柯林斯和P. 杜吉德,1989;T.A. 乌克兰涅茨,1998)所提出的语言知识的情境依赖构建,但也表明对话和形式化评估情境中的语言使用存在一定程度的重叠。