Bodner Ehud, Lazar Aryeh
Interdisciplinary Department of Social Sciences, Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan, Israel.
Int Psychogeriatr. 2008 Oct;20(5):1046-58. doi: 10.1017/S1041610208007151. Epub 2008 Apr 11.
Research concerning negative attitudes toward the elderly among samples of North American respondents has uncovered two distinct yet comparable three-factor structures: (1) avoidance, antilocution and separation; and (2) discrimination, stereotypes and affective attitudes. In addition, previous research has demonstrated that men and younger people have more negative attitudes toward the elderly than do women and older people. The aim of this study is to examine the extent to which these findings can be generalized to individuals from a different culture.
The Fraboni Scale of Ageism (FSA) was administered to 491 Israeli participants aged 20-50 years.
Exploratory factor analysis with varimax rotation uncovered a three-factor structure, similar to previous investigations. In contrast to the literature, however, no simple group (gender, age) differences were found for ageism. However, discriminant function analysis revealed a more complex relationship between age, gender and ageism. Older males, in contrast to older females, demonstrated a tendency to perceptions of the elderly that associated avoidance of the elderly with negative stereotypes whereas older females, in contrast to younger females, held perceptions that associated avoidance of the elderly with a negative perception of the elderly person's contribution to society.
Despite cultural differences between Israel and North America, the similarity of findings provides support for the generalizabilty of the structure of attitudes toward the elderly as measured by the FSA to various cultures. In addition, the combined effect of age and gender on differential forms of ageism is complex and should be examined in future research.
针对北美受访者样本中对老年人的消极态度的研究发现了两种不同但可比的三因素结构:(1)回避、言语诋毁和隔离;(2)歧视、刻板印象和情感态度。此外,先前的研究表明,男性和年轻人对老年人的态度比女性和老年人更消极。本研究的目的是检验这些发现能在多大程度上推广到来自不同文化的个体。
对491名年龄在20至50岁之间的以色列参与者施行了弗拉博尼年龄歧视量表(FSA)。
采用方差最大化旋转的探索性因素分析揭示了一种三因素结构,与先前的研究相似。然而,与文献不同的是,未发现年龄歧视存在简单的群体(性别、年龄)差异。但是,判别函数分析揭示了年龄、性别与年龄歧视之间更复杂的关系。与老年女性相比,老年男性表现出一种对老年人的认知倾向,即将回避老年人与负面刻板印象联系起来;而与年轻女性相比,老年女性的认知是将回避老年人与对老年人对社会贡献的负面看法联系起来。
尽管以色列和北美之间存在文化差异,但研究结果的相似性为通过FSA测量的对老年人态度结构在不同文化中的可推广性提供了支持。此外,年龄和性别对不同形式年龄歧视的综合影响是复杂的,应在未来研究中加以考察。