Pade Jürgen, Hummel Thomas
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, St. Johannes Hospital, Dortmund, Germany.
Laryngoscope. 2008 Jul;118(7):1260-4. doi: 10.1097/MLG.0b013e318170b5cb.
OBJECTIVE/HYPOTHESIS: This prospective study aimed to investigate predictors of nasal surgery in terms of olfactory function.
Prospective study.
A total of 775 patients were included in this prospective study (482 men, 293 women; age range 10-81 years, mean age 41 years, standard deviation = 15.3 y). Prior to surgery, patients received a detailed otorhinolaryngologic examination including nasal endoscopy. Olfactory function was assessed with a standardized odor identification test ("Sniffin' Sticks"). In 356 patients, olfactory function was retested 4 months after surgery (63-339 days after surgery; mean 128 days, standard deviation = 29 days); 206 of these patients received sinus surgery, while 150 received surgery involving the septum.
Using a conservative definition of change of olfactory function, following sinus surgery, improvement of the sense of smell was found in 23%, no change was seen in 68%, and decreased function was seen in 9% of the patients; in patients with septum surgery, improvement was seen in 13%, no change in 81%, and decreased function in 7%. Patients exhibiting a postoperative decrease of olfactory function had significantly higher preoperative olfactory scores than patients who experienced improvement. In terms of the sense of smell, nasal surgery produced the highest success rates in patients with eosinophilia and a high degree of polyposis. Neither age nor sex had a major impact on the outcome of surgery in terms of olfactory function.
These results in a large group of patients confirm previous work. Apart from apparent success in 13 to 23% of patients, there is also a small but significant group of patients (7 to 9%) in whom olfactory function decreases after surgery. Because this decrease was mostly found in patients with relatively good preoperative olfactory function, this group should receive specific attention when counseling patients about the potential risks of nasal surgery.
目的/假设:这项前瞻性研究旨在调查嗅觉功能方面鼻腔手术的预测因素。
前瞻性研究。
本前瞻性研究共纳入775例患者(482例男性,293例女性;年龄范围10 - 81岁,平均年龄41岁,标准差 = 15.3岁)。手术前,患者接受了包括鼻内镜检查在内的详细耳鼻喉科检查。嗅觉功能通过标准化气味识别测试(“嗅觉棒”)进行评估。356例患者在术后4个月(术后63 - 339天;平均128天,标准差 = 29天)重新进行嗅觉功能测试;其中206例患者接受了鼻窦手术,150例患者接受了鼻中隔手术。
采用嗅觉功能变化的保守定义,鼻窦手术后,23%的患者嗅觉改善,68%的患者无变化,9%的患者嗅觉功能下降;鼻中隔手术患者中,13%的患者嗅觉改善,81%的患者无变化,7%的患者嗅觉功能下降。术后嗅觉功能下降的患者术前嗅觉评分显著高于嗅觉改善的患者。在嗅觉方面,鼻腔手术在嗜酸性粒细胞增多和息肉程度较高的患者中成功率最高。年龄和性别对嗅觉功能方面的手术结果均无重大影响。
这些在大量患者中的结果证实了先前的研究。除了13%至23%的患者明显成功外,还有一小部分但数量可观的患者(7%至9%)术后嗅觉功能下降。由于这种下降主要发生在术前嗅觉功能相对较好的患者中,在向患者咨询鼻腔手术潜在风险时,这组患者应受到特别关注。