Klein Joern, Hussain Manzoor, Ahmad Munir, Afzal Muhammad, Alexandersen Soren
National Veterinary Institute, Technical University of Denmark, Lindholm, DK-4771 Kalvehave, Denmark.
Virol J. 2008 Apr 29;5:53. doi: 10.1186/1743-422X-5-53.
Foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) is endemic in Pakistan and causes huge economic losses. This work focus on the Landhi Dairy Colony (LDC), located in the suburbs of Karachi. LDC is the largest Buffalo colony in the world, with more than 300,000 animals (around 95% buffaloes and 5% cattle, as well as an unknown number of sheep and goats). Each month from April 2006 to April 2007 we collected mouth-swabs from apparently healthy buffaloes and cattle, applying a convenient sampling based on a two-stage random sampling scheme, in conjunction with participatory information from each selected farm. Furthermore, we also collected epithelium samples from animals with clinical disease, as well as mouth-swabs samples from those farms. In addition, we analysed a total of 180 serum samples randomly collecting 30 samples each month at the local slaughterhouse, from October 2006 to March 2007. Samples have been screened for FMDV by real-time RT-PCR and the partial or full 1D coding region of selected isolates has been sequenced. Serum samples have been analysed by applying serotype-specific antibody ELISA and non-structural proteins (NSP) antibody ELISA.
FMDV infection prevalence at aggregate level shows an endemic occurrence of FMDV in the colony, with peaks in August 2006, December 2006 and February 2007 to March 2007. A significant association of prevalence peaks to the rainy seasons, which includes the coldest time of the year and the muslimic Eid-festival, has been demonstrated. Participatory information indicated that 88% of all questioned farmers vaccinate their animals. Analysis of the serum samples showed high levels of antibodies for serotypes O, A, Asia 1 and C. The median endpoint-titre for all tested serotypes, except serotype C, in VNT titration is at a serum dilution of equal or above 1/100. All 180 serum samples collected have been tested for antibodies against the non-structural proteins and all but four have been found positive. Out of the 106 swab-samples from apparently healthy and affected animals positive in real-time RT-PCR, we sequenced the partial or full 1D coding region from 58 samples. In addition we sequenced the full 1D coding region of 17 epithelium samples from animals with clinical signs of FMD. From all sequenced samples, swabs and epithelium, 19 belong to the regional PanAsia II lineage of serotype O and 56 to the A/Iran/2005 lineage of serotype A.
For an effective and realisable FMD control program in LDC, we suggest to introduce a twice annually mass vaccination of all buffaloes and cattle in the colony. These mass vaccinations should optimally take place shortly before the beginning of the two rainy periods, e.g. in June and September. Those vaccinations should, in our opinion, be in addition to the already individually performed vaccinations of single animals, as the latter usually targets only newly introduced animals. This suggested combination of mass vaccination of all large ruminants with the already performed individually vaccination should provide a continuous high level of herd immunity in the entire colony. Vaccines used for this purpose should contain the matching vaccine strains, i.e. as our results indicate antigens for A/Iran/2005 and the regional type of serotype O (PanAsia II), but also antigens of the, in this world region endemic, Asia 1 lineage should be included. In the long term it will be important to control the vaccine use, so that subclinical FMD will be avoided.
口蹄疫(FMD)在巴基斯坦呈地方性流行,造成巨大经济损失。本研究聚焦于位于卡拉奇郊区的兰迪奶牛场(LDC)。LDC是世界上最大的水牛养殖场,存栏超过30万头动物(约95%为水牛,5%为奶牛,还有数量不明的绵羊和山羊)。从2006年4月至2007年4月,我们每月从看似健康的水牛和奶牛中采集口腔拭子,采用基于两阶段随机抽样方案的便捷抽样方法,并结合每个选定农场的参与性信息。此外,我们还从患有临床疾病的动物身上采集上皮组织样本,以及来自这些农场的口腔拭子样本。另外,我们在2006年10月至2007年3月期间,于当地屠宰场每月随机采集30份血清样本,共分析了180份血清样本。通过实时RT-PCR对样本进行口蹄疫病毒(FMDV)筛查,并对选定毒株的部分或完整1D编码区进行测序。血清样本采用血清型特异性抗体ELISA和非结构蛋白(NSP)抗体ELISA进行分析。
总体水平上FMDV感染患病率表明该养殖场存在FMDV地方性流行情况,在2006年8月、2006年12月以及2007年2月至3月出现高峰。已证实患病率高峰与雨季显著相关,雨季包括一年中最寒冷的时期以及穆斯林的开斋节。参与性信息表明,所有接受询问的农民中有88%为其动物接种疫苗。血清样本分析显示,针对O、A、亚洲1型和C型血清型存在高水平抗体。除C型血清型外,所有测试血清型在病毒中和试验(VNT)滴定中的中位终点滴度在血清稀释度等于或高于1/100时出现。所采集的180份血清样本均进行了非结构蛋白抗体检测,除4份外其余均呈阳性。在实时RT-PCR检测中呈阳性的106份来自看似健康和患病动物的拭子样本中,我们对58份样本的部分或完整1D编码区进行了测序。此外,我们还对17份有口蹄疫临床症状动物的上皮组织样本的完整1D编码区进行了测序。在所有测序样本(拭子和上皮组织)中,19份属于O型血清型的区域泛亚II系,56份属于A/伊朗/2005系的A型血清型。
为在LDC实施有效且可行的口蹄疫防控计划,我们建议对养殖场内所有水牛和奶牛每年进行两次大规模疫苗接种。这些大规模疫苗接种应在两个雨季开始前不久进行,例如在6月和9月。我们认为,这些疫苗接种应在已对单头动物进行的个体疫苗接种基础上进行,因为后者通常仅针对新引入的动物。建议的对所有大型反刍动物进行大规模疫苗接种与已实施的个体疫苗接种相结合的方式,应能在整个养殖场提供持续高水平的群体免疫力。用于此目的的疫苗应包含匹配的疫苗毒株,即如我们的结果所示,应包含A/伊朗/2005的抗原以及O型血清型的区域类型(泛亚II)的抗原,同时还应包含在该世界区域呈地方性流行的亚洲1系的抗原。从长远来看,控制疫苗使用以避免亚临床口蹄疫至关重要。